I did not know when technical analysis got introduced to retail participants. Institutions may have got access to TA, and other data and price related technologies decades ago, and as such, there may have existed certain market inefficiencies in the past in our market, due to information asymmetry and tech not reaching retail.
Efficient market hypothesis may just be a hypothesis, but considering the availability of information, the reach and speed at which everyone has access to it now, and many things pertaining to the market are available for free on internet, a lot of things are becoming common knowledge, and as such, have you observed anything in particular in your experience which you think has changed w.r.t TA and will remain so, and will not go back to its initial state?
To put it simply sir, if everyone knows about candlesticks, patterns, trend lines, support and resistance, Fibonacci etc, and take actions based on these aspects, and not panicking and selling unlike before, has the chance of a view based on TA becoming true is less now, or TA is TA, has been the same for centuries, and will remain the same, it is the fundamental investors who move the price in general, for them TA does not matter, their focus is on the business and valuations, and there will always be humans emotions present, so the probability of TA becoming true or false will always be the same, and can be relied upon, with caveats?
Your selfless service to this great forum is unmatchable in terms of educating the retail investors like me.
Words are not just enough to appreciate your kindness with respect to sharing your vast knowledge.
To be honest, I’m a kind of a person who never looks in to charts. But after reading your posts I’m slowly changing my perception.
I have depicted my understanding via 2 pictures below.
To my limited understanding, I see 2 consecutive cup & handle in different time periods.
Near handle area, volumes are diminishing.
Additionally, KVB is moving in a tight range/not going down in-spite of the ongoing downtrend in overall market. I see this as a strength.
However, I’m not sure whether my understanding is correct or not.
I’m also not sure about the 2nd chart. Shape of cup & handle is not ideal…
Inputs/thought process from your side with regard to this would be a good learning going forward.
Fundamentally, KVB is increasing the profits in last few quarters & NPA is also on decreasing trend.
Both technical analysis and fundamental analysis have been in vogue since decades. I think Homma introduced candlesticks a few centuries ago. And it’s still being used by people practising TA. You will find people swearing by Ben Graham’s tenets even now after nearly 8-9 decades.
The most recent fad in technical analysis is swing trading and breakouts. You will find a lot of videos on Youtube giving a list of breakout stocks every week, some every few days and so on. A lot of Whatsapp groups related to investing and TA will have plenty of breakout patterns being shared. Once a lot of people start using these things without proper understanding, the efficacy of these things will reduce. That is one of the reasons why we are seeing a lot of breakouts going in for retests, and these retests are often frustrating. What these short cut methods fail to teach is patience and temperament. The latter are two important aspects of investing and trading that are less emphasised. These are the very reasons why a lot of retail investors with half baked knowledge and skills tend to over commit and panic and this leads to a lot of wild swings in markets. It’s probably one of the reasons why we have market cycles that have become very short.
The way to navigate around these kind of problems is to broaden your horizon, and inculcate some fundamental analysis also while going in for technical analysis, or vice versa. And try to go in for some well tested methods which few people follow. When everyone is looking around for multiyear breakouts, it might make sense to go around looking for bottoming formations. Or something else.
I think both TA and FA will continue to work and reward those who keep learning, improving and have sound processes and temperament.
For investing purposes, try looking at weekly or monthly charts, especially in companies with good/improving fundamentals. On monthly chart of KVB, cup and handle is clearly visible if you draw a horizontal line at 116. On daily charts there will be a lot of noise and whipsaws, so better focus on slightly longer term charts, esp if you are into investing.
And as discussed in earlier post, there can be a lot of retest like moves, and we have to be ready for that, or even better, learn to take advantage of those moves.
I have few doubts on the cup and handle pattern as seen in KVB on a monthly time frame.
Isn’t the cup too deep and the correction in the cup more than ~>30% as stated by O’ Niel (KVB - Max. - 116 , Min. - 22).
O’ Niel also mentions that major part of the cup should be formed above the average depth, which here doesn’t seem to be the scenario.
Similar example is the Coforge cup and handle on weekly time frame.
If you would be so kind to please help me clear these doubts. I am pretty new to TA and categorised this cup and handle as a loose cup and handle pattern due to the above mentioned points.
Sir I think if more people start using these things without proper knowledge, the efficacy of proper practices in FA & TA will increase. Improperly followed investing and trading practices will increase the size and number of opportunities and make markets more inefficient & a better hunting ground for professionals.
In my humble opinion, “Permanent ownership” could sometimes be a trap. If a company has been giving consistent returns for years together and suddenly goes into consolidation for say, 2 years, it might probably prudent to switch over to some other fundamentally sound company that is performing much better during this period. Any particular business may face trouble for some period and we always have choice to come back.
Recently most people that I know off : people are just investing by the name so called “ordebook investing”
The kind of rally that was in railway just scares me off that too 4x within a year…
How one should look at sectors like power, railway or construction wherein the major orders for these are government?
Because my past experience in public sector is too bad, how one should look at order book investing and given the fact that elections are close what’s your views on order books backed by government, is there any risk?
Whenever you find a sector in favour, you will find froth. Initial phase of the rally is with disbelief, then it progresses with acceptance, and then comes frothy narratives. Order book investing is a kind of frothy situation. But this kind of stuff can also keep going on for months, before shit hits the fan.
Riding momentum is a specialised skill. It’s not everyone’s cup of tea. While riding momentum, many a times there will be extreme discomfort while justifying valuations. (Does not mean we have to ignore fundamental picture altogether). But we should know that these kind of rallies tend to last much longer than what most people expect.
What I do is plan staggered exits once I see parabolic moves start happening. ( with sector in fancy, usually there are parabolic breath taking climatic moves… e.g mazgaon dock … )
After that even if stock price trends to go higher than my sell price, I don’t regret my decisions, because we cannot sell at the absolute top.
Above is the kind of framework I use while riding momentum stocks and sectors.
Railways, defence seem to be the sectors in fancy as of now. And some of the stocks are in the parabolic upmove phase. One needs to exercise caution while making a fresh entry.
Can you share your views on Shipping Corporation of India. It is within Breakout range. The Baltic dry index is improving which I feel is positive for company.
Dear Hitesh Sir , on the same note it will be great to get your views on Cochin Shipyard and GE Shipping . Cochin shipyard is transforming fundamentally inline with Govt vision to make India a significant contributor to shipping industry by 2030. They have actually started bagging orders from Europe for small sea vessels , some 2400 odd nos are due for replacement, they have got order of 14 so far plus their AR talks about lots of initiatives. GE shipping again in line with baltic index, last several qtrs have been good for them. Thanks.
Fundamentally I don’t track Cochin shipyard, or GE shipping or Baltic index. But the chart of Cochin shipyard is a beautiful example of a rounding formation and then a big upmove. Below 700, the consolidation took form of a rounding formation and once it broke out above that levels, it went up to post highs of 1258 and now again seems to be in a pause mode.
Current times are good times for anything with a PSU tag attached. And may they continue. But again like other rallies of favoured sectors in the past, I consider these are sectoral rallies with strong tailwinds and have to be dealt with accordingly. I would not dare to project earnings beyond maybe 2 years. With govt companies a lot of unforeseen things can happen. But as long as the music lasts, we should dance, but stay close to the exit doors when music becomes too loud.
There is structural shift is happening in Carbon Black Supply Chain starting from Raw Material to Finished Good Demand.
China has gone due to environmental norms and other raw material issues. Russia has banned by Western countries.
Only option left with western world is India. And all supply vacuum from China and Russia shall be filled by India. Moreover PCBL is the only Largest and Efficient Indian Manufacturer which will definitely capitalise to this opportunity.
Also PCBL is improving sales from Speciality Grade Carbon Black which is with higher and stable margin. So in future Operating Margin will improve.
Investment Thesis is: Sales Growth, Operating Margin Improvement, PAT and ROCE expansion, May announce large capex soon (recent conference call), Rerating opportunity in valuation
What can go wrong: China again entering market, crude oil prices remaining very high for long, Auto industry slowdown (high sales of CB in Tyres)
Disc: Invested (May be biased) with Large Allocation @ 150.
I don’t track PCBL. I usually track only a few other companies beyond the ones I already own. These are mainly stand by candidates in case I have to replace any company in my portfolio. Or in some other cases where I feel that it’s worth studying and following that company for a variety of reasons.
Wherever I find any interesting technical picks I share in the 52 weeks high thread.
As a retail investor, Is it possible to identify Next sector in line at early stage ?
Q1. Typically, by what time frame/by which means do retail investors become aware of a promising sector ?
Q2. Which could be the Big funds/ Big guys to follow, to learn about the sector in the favour ?
If i find recently launched certain quant fund investing in telecom hardware, telecom software, telecom infrastructure, Can we say telecom could be one of the next sector in focus ?
Hi Hitesh - How has being a full time investor changed things for you?
Are there things you can do now (investing - wise) that you couldn’t earlier, if so what are they?
Are you able to cast a wider net in terms of companies you can research etc?
Don’t want to ask too many specific questions, want to keep it more open ended and for you to answer this question however you like, just wanted to get your experience of how being a “full time” investor has differed from your previous experiences.
Clearly achieving financial freedom is a precursor to jumping in full time as an investor, But on behalf of the rest of us that have also taken the plunge - wanted to get an idea of how your experience has differed from our own.
It is more easy for a retail investor to spot the next sector if he/she keeps observing price actions in various sectors over a period of time.
Simplest thing to do is to keep watching the 52 weeks high list on a regular basis. If a lot of stocks from the same sector start featuring in this list on a consistent basis, then it makes sense to have a look at chart patterns of individual stocks.
If most of them start showing bullish formations of similar or different kinds, then it adds to the conviction. Next step is to listen to the commentary of these companies wherever possible and do some digging.
If all the above things fall in place, then you have probably stumbled on to the next big sector. Next thing is to observe the behaviour of these bunch of stocks during days where markets are weak. If these show more resilience as compared to overall markets, and start moving once the market start a strong rally, then you have hit the jackpot. Within these group of stocks some of them will often move quickly, rest will follow.
But there are some sectors typically related to cyclical industries, where the cycles tend to run shorter. In other sectors often the rallies last much longer. Observing sectors in fancy over a period of time helps in figuring out these things.
Personally I do not folllow what big guys/big funds or quant funds are doing. I have described the process I follow above and usually that helps in getting into a few sectors early on. Many a times I miss a sector or two due to various reasons, but that’s something that’s okay to live with. We don’t need to win all the races. Idea is to make the most of your winners.