Greetings! I deeply appreciate your selfless work here. I hope you continue guiding us for a very very long time.
My journey in stock starts in may-22 by trying to catch falling knives…my pack went -30%…it made me read more…Stumbled across doctor’s Kaveri seeds story. Thats how I found VP & your portfolio thread…I keep that news story & your PF thread bookmarked…I consider it to be the best thing happened to me in my investment journey so far.
Currently, about 90% of my investments are in small-caps, focusing on what you call “flavors of the season” such as defense, government, and electrical capital goods (with financials, materials, and industrial making up 75%, and IT at 15%). I have None in chemicals, pharma, textile, and packaging, which I tried to chase in 2H 2022.
My queries:
In terms of “flavors of the season,” how can i identify when a sector is losing its appeal or becoming more favorable, especially if I am not adept at reading charts or financials? (I am asking because I feel this is what made me stay afloat and this could be the right approach for non-number fellas like me who expect more than 20% return, I was lucky to somehow get hitched to the flavorful wagon…my pack today is +30% from -30% in May-22. I feel luck would not be always on same side)
I wish to have more clarity if the growth in the electrical capital goods sector might continue until 2025 due to India’s 2030 renewable apirations, which require more capital goods in electricals? I’ve traded multiple times with successes into HBL, TRIL and Technoe in the past. Today I hold two of them as the top two in my portfolio.
My investment approach has been “jump on good names when market takes deeper cut ". I found myself to be adding more and more every time market dives. This approach brings me to about 35 stocks in my pack. I wish to have guidence on this and if its okay to have such nos in the pack. ?
As someone who works full-time and has limited time for in-depth research, would you recommend, following ValuePickr senior members, the 52-week high thread, or the Bull Therapy thread as a suitable approach to learn and invest?
That’s all for now. I have more questions, and I would greatly appreciate your guidance. Would it be okay to come back with more questions in the future?
As a minor addition to these excellent points by Hitesh ji.
A recent blog entry capturing some of the idle-time itches which affect a full time investor.
Thoughts. Actions. Results. These three need not be always related.
Dear Hitesh bhai thanks for the wisdom . I have a few questions on point you mentioned
With regards to concentration of bets on stocks where you have conviction and growth looks convincing. Whats is a good allocation at one point 7 % was good for me today i feel going north of 10 % upto 20 % . I know it depends on person to person but what is a good allocation considering risk of blow up is low and portfolio can grow @ high Cagr with mediocre risk
In a concentrated portfolio of say 10 stocks how many should be high allocation bets ( assume we have 5 high convincing idea )
a) 3 stock 20 % allocation each rest 5 % each
b) 3 stock with 10 % allocation rest with 5-7 %
c) 5 stock with 10 % each balance 5 -7 %
I intend to follow option a) wanted to understand your view and also which one of above looks good or any staryegy that you follow which works for you.
Concentration does give excitement of higher double digit growth in portfolio but also comes with risk of portfolio moving in either direction.
Regarding allocation in a particular portfolio, there is an endless debate. There is no holy grail.
Allocation style depends upon an individual’s comfort levels. I have a close friend, ( don’t want to name him) who is scared to go beyond 10-12% allocation in his highest conviction bets. For me it is often the minimum starting position in my highest conviction bets. And both of us have near identical records.
But there are certain situations where there is confirmation of a good story from multiple vantage points. For someone like me, having knowledge of technicals also is an added advantage. If I find a good company with improving fundamentals crossing key 52 week, or multi year high levels, I feel added conviction and find it easy to increase allocations.
I know of some investor friends, who dig deep into fundamentals ( not my forte), often attend management concalls, AGMs, have a close eye on the industry scenario, track competitors etc, and they too have their own ways of getting added parameters in a high conviction story. I know for a fact that they do not indulge in chart reading. But they have found and sharpened their own methods of getting conviction, and tracking company on a regular basis.
I am not good at statistical models, I am more of a feel based investor, more intuitive, more instinctive, when it comes to allocation part in my portfolio. So I would have no answers to the different scenarios you have put up. You will have to make your own peace with those problems with experience and trial and error.
But highly concentrated positions have often worked for me. The most important attribute for a concentrated investor is to be nimble and decisive. If any of my high concentration bets seem to be on shaky grounds, I am very quick and decisive in reducing/totally exiting my positions. Post this actions, even if my call has gone wrong, in cutting my positions, I don’t suffer from any regrets.
A lot of selling aspect of whatever I feel and have learned is shared a few posts back in following post. Nothing more to add.
Regarding which thread to follow, it’s your own call. These are threads put up more to share learnings and understanding technicals, including different easy to understand patterns. Looking at 52 week highs, multi year highs, simple trendline breakouts, etc should not involve too much complicated learning. These are practical, mostly live examples in the Indian context. These are not recommendations, and hence need to be read for learning purposes.
Doing what you love is happiness and for me its investing ! What a message Sir !
Sir, I have been doing Asset Allocation & aggressive rebalancing since last 22 months and have been managing 23-24% XIRR consistently. Majorly its ETF & Index Funds rotation (Large, Mid, Small, Nasdaq, IT & Goldbees). Its peaceful , easy to track and let me be honest- keeps me happy.
Now that I have completed 1 bear and 1 bull cycle ( Bull is still on though), I am thinking of leverage in the next bear cycle. Obviously not a huge amount, but thinking of taking OD on FD or other safe instruments whereby interest rate shall be less than 10%. Overall leverage would be 30-40% and own funds would be 70-60%. Ability to hold for 5 years as have regular salaried income.
Thank you so much and my deep gratitude to you for always handholding investors so that their learning curve is fast with less mistakes. Am amazed and wonderstruck with the regularity with which you have been replying to learning investors like me over a long period, with practical solutions. Practical suggestions like you give are never found anywhere else in any book.
Have followed averaging on the up rather than down after your suggestion long time back and have found it to be comfortable now though initially it was uncomfortable as it was going against the instinct.
I have often found myself unable to cut losses when it goes down.
How does one be nimble and decisive without being regretful ? How to change this instinct ?
Leverage is a double edged sword. If you know how to use it, it can win you wars, and if you don’t it can hurt you.
While using leverage, the key remains to control greed. A definite level ( as you mention 30-40% ) of leverage has to be fixed beyond which no matter what, you will not go. If there is this kind of discipline, then maybe there can be a case of leverage. Other aspect is that if markets turns in the direction opposite to your anticipation, you will have to take quick decisions.
I do not have any experience of leverage except in my early days when for a brief spell I used to dabble in F&O, but was lucky enough to exit with minimal scars. Those days luckily I did not have enough money to lose. I have heard some friends use leverage on their own holdings to buy other holdings, but this thing has never appealed to me.
Cutting losses, and that too as quickly as possible is a learning on investment journey. I used to be slow to take losses and often took hits of nearly 20-40% on my positions. But during Covid crash, I somehow managed to exit extremely quickly during the first phase of fall itself and that helped me get over the mental block of booking losses quickly
Usually whenever you are attempting something new, first couple of times, its difficult, but once you start doing it regularly and start seeing the results, it becomes second nature.
The only drawback to this strategy is that sometimes after your quick exit in any position, the stock price will start moving up and often with vengeance. We have to learn to make peace with this kind of scenario. That too comes with experience. This kind of stuff has to be taken philosophically. You cannot win them all. You win some, you lose some. But whenever you are in a winning position, make sure to make the most of it.
Wondering if Dr. Reddy’s is currently a cup and handle pattern?
My style of investing was buying compounders on dips. However after reading through your posts and multiple other books - I am very intrigued by ‘techno funda’
In that light, would a company like Dr. Reddy’s qualify for this style given the cyclical nature of Pharma?
Dr Reddys stock price crossed its previous all time high of 4380 in July 2020 in the Covid pharma rally. It then went on to hit a fresh all time high of 5600 in July 2021 and went into consolidation, and posted a swing low of 3660 in March 2022. Since then it has had a good upmove, and it crossed the highs posted in July 2021 in July 2023 ( highs posted and crossed all in July? ) and went on to high a swing high of 5989 and came down to retest previous highs. Now seems to be consolidating.
The move from July 2021 to July 2023 is a rounding structure. It does not have a typical cup and handle structure, but overall chart looks good.
Regarding techno funda, any company qualifies for techno funda. We have discussed so many ideas in the 52 weeks high thread.
When people despite knowing but haven’t experienced talk about things, there could be an element of doubt, that they might not know in full, and that their suggestion should be taken with a pinch of salt, but not with your sir.
Personally, I don’t think there isn’t a thing that you cannot provide an answer to.
I haven’t come across anyone mentioning about second nature, a nature that is the result of deliberate practice. And being philosophical too, with the outcomes. Probability with a touch of philosophy. Couldn’t agree more.
You are a great teacher, a teacher with knowledge, experience and wisdom, with an approach, and answers that are succinct and comprehensible to all of us. Even your one liners come with a lot of weight and profound meaning.
Hi Hitesh Sir,
Can you please share your opinion on the charts of HCL Tech? The stocks after making a bottom at around 870 (May 2021, July 2022 and September 2022) seem to have found the base and have started inching towards their all-time highs.
It has already been 2 years of bear market in IT Stocks and pessimism has not faded yet. Time to go contrarian?
The whole large cap IT pack has been in a long consolidation mode since a long time… Some of them might be breaking out, but I don’t track the sector or any stock in the sector .
@hitesh2710 Hello sir,
Can you please share your opinion on bectors food because currently at quite high valuation but the business has a literally long way to go because they are planning out to pan out their distribution to whole country
According to my charts, Nifty 200 day exponential moving avg is at 18646 ( can vary by a few points according to platform you use ) and 200 day simple moving avg is at 18466. I don’t know how you estimate that it’s 50 odd points short of 200 dma…
Coming to actual factual numbers, Nifty made three bottoms in vicinity of 19200 in August 2023. Intervening peak was at 19585. This was a sort of double/triple bottom kind of pattern confirmation on shorter time frame and after that Nifty rallied to a high of 20222. Since that high we are in a corrective mode and around 19700 levels as of now… Need to see how the next few days pan out.
I would like to hear your views about the recent announcement of Glenmark Pharma selling 75% of it’s stake in Glenmark Life Sciences to Nirma, which is a relatively new entrant in the pharma space.
Nirmal will get 75% plus shares that will be tendered in the mandatory open offer process. There is an old history with Nirma not treating the minority shareholders well. Times have changed now. Any advice for shareholders of GLS that want to hold their shares as the GLS business is quite good?
Hitesh ji, Very nice work you are doing here. Your clarity of thought is awesome.
Just one query.
In some of your posts , you have commented on chemical sector. Your point is , Chemical sector is basically a commodity sector amd recently in last 2 years, it had caught market fancy. Companies like Deepak Nitrate, Alkyl amines have been 7-8 bagger from 2019. But in last 1 year, all these stocks are down by 30% or more from its ATH. So you are concluding that , market fancy has been off now and these companies will take lot of time, may be years , to come to their recent glory, from your past experience of market fancies in past sectors. It appears that your conclusion is correct. So those retail investors who like me, who are invested in these companies are essentially caught up in these companies. But can it be so, that most investors also advise that never invest into market fancies and stay away from them, rather invest into such sectors which are beaten down and not in the current fancy of the market. If we go by that logic, then is it the best time to invest in chemical comanies? I remember Fundoo Professor video about “Opposite of good can also be good.”. So what can be right really? Staying invested or coming out of it? Recently I read Pulak Prasad Book. He has advocated Permanent ownership in good companies. So those companies which are not doing good pricewise, we still need to hold on to it, irrespective of market fancy. Kindly advise. Thanks in advance.
Chemical sector had a strong rally mainly due to some strong industry specific tailwinds. Most important among them was the shortages in key chemicals due to shutdown in chemical companies in China due to pollution control measures. To that was added the China plus one theory post Covid. All this resulted in a heady cocktail which led to big crazy rally in chemical sector and a lot of stocks went up manifold within a short period of time.
The run up had been so strong that it occupied investor mindspace, and even after it has been in the doldrums since many months , a lot of investors are still not able to figure out the commodity nature of the business. While most of the companies in the sector are commodity type companies, there will be a few of them which because of their products, or business models, or niche will be less commoditised and these can be considered. But for that a lot of homework needs to be done to understand the business and come to the right conclusions.
Regarding investing in neglected sectors, we have to understand what we mean by neglected sector. According to me, a neglected sector is one where the cheapness of stocks on conventional parameters is obvious. Say based on PE, P/B etc. Few months back, the PSU stocks basket was one such space. Since past 3-4 quarters, these banks had been posting extremely good Y-on-Y growth in numbers, with improvement in asset quality, good management commentary and some of them had amazing dividend yields of more than 5%. Consider REC and PFC (though slightly different from PSU banks, but can qualify as PSU NBFC) which had nearly 10% or more dividend yields. And now see the kind of returns these companies have generated. Look at the kind of market apathy these companies and sectors suffered and since how long… That is an example of neglected sector.
Pulak Prasad advocates buying into good companies for very very long term. But here too, we need to define what a good company is… Can it be a chemical company which is vulnerable to raw material prices volatility, end product demand fluctuations etc? For what a truly great company is, we need to go to Warren Buffett’s definition of a good company. Or read Peter Lynch on consistent growers or stalwart companies. These may qualify for long term or near permanent ownership. ( In this day and age, I am not a big fan of commiting myself to permanent ownership of a business. But that’s also partly how I am wired to think. )
@newone I don’t track Glenmark or any of its group companies or their corporate developments.