C2C Advanced Systems: Specialized Defence Play

C2C Advanced systems

About us:

We’re an Indian private sector company at the forefront of product development in mission-critical applications. Our expertise includes C4I systems, AI/ML-based big data analytics, and enterprise integration of real-time data from IIoT and embedded/FPGA designs. As the first Indian startup in the defense sector, we’ve delivered Combat Management Systems (CMS) for two Malaysian Naval Frigate Ships. With over 5 years of experience and 190 employees, we’ve delivered battle-proven systems globally. Our success in selling and executing our “Combat Management System” (CMS) to the Royal Malaysian Navy against global competition demonstrates our capabilities. This remains one of the most successful demonstrations of an intelligent platform from India. C2C Advanced Systems can re-engineer and revamp legacy Indian military systems to meet current warfare needs. As a pre-eminent domain-agnostic technology company focused on “Intelligent Platform,” we have a technological advantage and globally competitive offerings. Our expertise in architecture design, data acquisition, data analytics, and AI/ML has dual use in civilian applications. The rigorous military requirements allow us to innovate for the highest levels of performance.

What is CMS (Combat Management Systems)?

A warship’s CMS is the brain of its combat capability. The CMS continuously interacts with all the ship’s sensors and weapons – including radar, sonar, missiles, rockets and torpedoes – and assesses the threats that they detect. Then, the CMS suggests weapons to neutralise the threat; and it fires and controls those weapons.

In addition, the sophisticated CMS software collaborates with friendly warships’ command systems over a real time datalink. This develops a “common operating picture” for fleet operations.

C2C supplied CMS to Royal Malaysian Navy in 2019 competing against Biggies of Defense Sector

This small firm partnered with a Malaysian firm, Marine Crest Technologies, to wrest the tightly contested RMN contract from global competitors such as Thales of France, Saab of Sweden and UK-headquartered BAE Systems. RMN placed the order for the two CMSs and tactical datalink systems in April 2018, stipulating a delivery period of just nine months for the first system. Typically, developing a similar system in India takes about two years.

With C2C demonstrating the complete functionality of the CMS and datalink during “factory acceptance trials” in January 2019, and the system shipped to Malaysia the next month, C2C Systems became the only Indian entity to have developed a complete CMS, along with a tactical datalink. It is also the only Indian entity to have exported such a system.

What apart from CMS?

The Ministry of Defence has announced the Defence Acquisition Procedure which has come into effect from October 1, 2020. This procedure focuses on significantly boosting indigenous production and turning India into a global manufacturing hub of weapons and military platforms.

The ‘Second Positive Indigenisation List’ comprises complex systems, sensors, simulator, weapons and ammunition, such as Helicopters, Next Generation Corvettes, Air Borne Early Warning and Control (AEW&C) systems, Tank Engines, Medium Power Radar for Mountains, MRSAM Weapon Systems and many more such items to fulfil the requirements of the Indian armed forces. This second list is planned to be implemented progressively with effect from Dec. 2021 to Dec. 2025.

Some of the products listed in the Import Embargo List such as Corvettes, Air Borne Early Warning and Control (AEW&C) systems, Tank Engines, Medium Power Radar are manufactured by C2C. It will help them in coming future to secure more significant orders.

Products:

The products that the Company supplies are:

  1. Combat Management System

  2. C4I Systems

  3. Anti Drone Command and Control System

  4. Air Defence Sub-systems

  5. Integrated Platform Management Systems

  6. Integrated Vessel Management System

All the products are in the form of code which is supplied to the clients who use them on their equipment.

Object of the Issue:

Management:

Lakshmi Chandra: MD of the company. She is also a director in C2C innovations and PVR multimedia. She holds a Bachelors degree in Social Sciences

from the Madras University and a Masters degree in Business Administration from the Rutgers University, New Jersey, USA. She has 18 years of experience as a technology licensing specialist and has about 10 years’ experience as a digital design specialist.

Kuryidath Ramesh holds the position of Chief Technology Officer (CTO) at the company. He enlisted in the Indian Navy in 1986 as a Naval Cadet. After completing his Bachelor of Technology (B.Tech.) degree in 1990 from the Indian Naval Academy (INS Shivaji), Ramesh retired from the Navy in 2011 after serving for approximately 25 years. Additionally, he pursued an Executive Management Course for Armed Forces Officers from the Indian Institute of Management (IIM) Bangalore.

Throughout his tenure in the Indian Navy, Ramesh served in various ships and establishments. As an Electrical Officer, he was responsible for the maintenance and availability of all power and weapon systems aboard Naval vessels.

Murtaza Ali Soomar: a commerce graduate brings about 2 decades of entrepreneurial experience to his current strategic position within the company.He is also the company CFO.

Lakshmi Chandra, Maya Chandra and Murtaza Ali Soomar holds the stake in C2C innovations and PVR multimedia (related companies).

Related Party Transactions:

  • As per the restated financial statements as on September 30, 2024 , the Company has availed total sum of 13 cr. as unsecured loans from promoters
  • 8 cr sales out of 41 cr sales are to a group company named Realtime Techsolutions Private Limited in the previous FY but nothing so far in this FY.
  • The company has given some advances to its group-related companies.

Valuations and Guidance:

Management is guiding for 200% CAGR growth for the next 3 years (Crazy. It means sales will grow 27x in the next 3 years. Hard to believe this.) Even if they achieve half of this, it can turn it into a midcap.

Management is confident of closing this year at 135 cr. sales with 30% NPM at 40 crores of Net Profit. You can assign a P/E ratio as per your understanding of Defence stocks.

FY Sales Profit
2022-23 8 2.88
2023-24 41.33 12.4
2024-25 (H1) 43.25 9.73
2024-25 (Guidance) 135 40

Risks:

  • Client concentration: The top five customers contributed 89.59% of revenues for the year ended March 31, 2024, and 99.05% for the period ended September 30, 2024, based on restated financial statements. The top ten customers contributed 100% of the revenues for the year ended March 31, 2024, and 99.05% for the period ended September 30, 2024.
  • High receivables: trade receivables days were 1,910 days and 4085 days for the financial years March 31, 2022, and March 31, 2023 and trade payable days were 7,811 days for the financial years March 31, 2022.
  • Might have to raise additional capital from time to time to handle working capital
  • As per the restated financial statements as on September 30, 2024 , the Company has availed total sum of 13 cr. as unsecured loans from promoters
  • Outstanding receivables: 31 cr. of outstanding receivables of more than 6 months as of Sep 30, 2024 and total receivable of 74 cr.
  • Group Company Realtime Tech Solutions Limited has defaulted for 1.42 cr. EPF payments.
  • Complex holding structure via multiple promoter companies

Management Guidance on WC days: They are expecting it to come down from 240 days to 150-180 days. Developing CMS is a 1-year product delivery cycle. Hence, they don’t expect it to go down significantly.

As per the management no other company in India has a complete CMS (product category C4I system)

Unresolved Mystery: The whole purpose of the IPO is to fund their elongated working capital. But then why they have given money to their group companies? Maybe these issues will get resolved after going public.

Disclosure: Invested
Today’s Market cap: 1408 cr.

Sources:

Most of the questions are answered in this interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCI9G_dy4eE

7 Likes

Hi there. I’ve been looking at the company and haven’t been able to figure out their customers in the last couple of years.

Understand that majority of their revenues are exports. Any idea who they may be supplying to ? The Malaysian deal was fairly long ago and would be factored into FY20 /21 revenues i’m guessing.

Overseas customers are ~ 93% revenues in 1H25.

Also their product wise split in their RHP is not very clear on the difference between defense / IP led projects and others.

Disclaimer: Interested but not invested.

1 Like

Hi Avneesh,

Thanks for starting this thread. C2C is a very interesting play on defence electronics and software both domestically and exports. After years of toil and hard work in past 4-5 years, it has received qualification certificate for its products in 2024 and this is a significant game changer moment in the company journey. Now it’s time for them to reap rewards with right execution next 2-3 years. For some of its products, it has no peers in india and very few competitors globally.

@Kunal93 They have supplied CMS on two NATO ships as a white-label partner to a NATO approved defence contractor in FY24 and H1 FY25. Company is now equally focusing on domestic as well as exports market and have many orders in pipeline.

As per TSG Capital report (attached), below is their order pipeline:::
● Currently, the company has outstanding proposals for over INR 200 Cr, and in some cases, it is the sole bidder.
Few projects that are expected to drive future growth :
● Truck Mounted Gun Control System : Proof of concept completed for Bharat Forge, potential order of INR 1,280 Cr
● WECDIS : Trials ongoing in Kochi Naval Dockyard, addressable market of 200 systems at INR 60 lakhs per system
● Combat Management System : Secured 3 additional orders for CMS from Malaysia, following the successful completion of the first project

Company is guiding for 130crs revenues with 25-30% PAT margins in FY25 (~35crs PAT) and trading at 38x FY25 PE. Also, driven by above strong order pipeline, they are guiding for 100-200% growth CAGR in next 2-3 years. So effectively, the PEG is just .3x for a defence software company with core IP/tech and no competitors

Also, top shareholders are all long term marquee investors in the company:::

Jeewan Patwa (Sahasra Capital) / Katkars - 10L shares (bought around 515 in pre-ipo secondary market)

Ashish Kacholia - 6.5L shares (bought last 1.5L shares at 450 in pre-ipo)

Mukul Aggarwal - 4.3L shares

Ankush Kedia - 3.2L shares

Negen (Neil Bahal) - 2.1L shares

Rakesh Laoria - 1.5L shares

6 Likes

C2C Notes - TSG_Capital-2.pdf (554.4 KB)

Report attached!!!

4 Likes

In interviews, they have declined to share customer information, citing confidentiality. However, Mukul’s TSG Capital note provides more detailed insights about their products and potential customer base. You can refer to it for further understanding of the business.

2 Likes

Thanks @avneesh and @fundoo . The TSG report definitely sheds more light on the order book and market opportunity.

Also the investor base, likes of Ashish Kacholia etc, lends more credence to their business plan confidence.

2 Likes

Searched a bit more on TSG Capital and its employees on LinkedIn.

Their CIO seems to have a total of ~6 years of work exp (some of it not in finance). They are based in Mumbai.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/nairit69/?originalSubdomain=in

Edit: Seems to be managing his family portfolio.

2 Likes

C2C has partnered with SIA - India to become gold sponsor for DEFSAT 2025 which is going to be held on Jan 8th to 10th in Delhi.

Company is also aggressively expanding its BD team to apply for more tenders globally as well as domestically:

https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/view/4108116879/?refId=GXDDDB57Qu6UNYqJrGSIfA%3D%3D&trackingId=GXDDDB57Qu6UNYqJrGSIfA%3D%3D

https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/view/4108992852/?refId=yH0cLeo%2BSgy1gccc2wfU%2Fw%3D%3D&trackingId=yH0cLeo%2BSgy1gccc2wfU%2Fw%3D%3D

With access to IPO funds, co is now looking to expand its team as well do industry level partnerships to achieve its growth targets.

1 Like

Company is participating in Bharat Ideas Conference 3.0 on 11th January. Would be a great opportunity for investors to understand the business in detail and get latest business updates.

————————————————————

BHARAT 3.0 INVESTORS’ CONFERENCE

Join us to understand the top MEGA TRENDS of the coming decade. Also get a chance to meet these companies 1x1 or in small group set up to understand more about the sectors/segments. List of participating companies:

1) Data Centers: ESDS - Leading made-in-india Date Center & digitization solutions (cloud managed services + SAAS + digital AI) player with strong end-to-end offerings.

2) e-mobility: PMI Electro - 2nd largest e-bus OEM in India with >20% market share & heading towards market leadership. Domestic opportunity size >$15-20bn. Listing soon.

3) Battery Storage: EMO Energy - Enabling an end-to-end Ecosystem for Batteries across Mobility & Storage by manufacturing & supplying battery packs.

4) Defence Automation: C2C Automation - Deep expertise in Command and Control (C2C) systems, radar technology, Artificial Intelligence and IoT based smart systems.

5) Robotics: Affordable Robotics - Present in 3 key robotic and automation segments – automated robotic welding, robotic multilevel parking, warehouse automation – targeting a $350bn market. Listed.

6) Cleanroom: Fabtech Cleanrooms Tech - Co is engaged in the business of manufacturing and providing design-to-validation solutions for pre-engineered & prefabricated modular panels & doors used in constructing cleanrooms for the pharma, healthcare & biotech sectors.

7) Defence Manufacturing: Atmastco - Focus is on manufacturing personal protective equipment (PPE), bulletproof jackets, advanced defense gear for soldiers and combat helmets for military use, emphasizing lightweight, high-protection designs. Listed

8) Private Charter Planes: Fly SBS - SBS Aviation (same founding team as Afcom) is a pioneer in the space of fulfilling the dream of owning the private jet aircraft, giving its customers the choice to experience the wide variety of Private Jets of their choice while paying only for the hours they need. Co has the vision to become the No.1 Private Jet Leasing Company in India. Listing soon.

9) Water Treatment: Jash Engg - Dedicated to offering varied products for use in Water and Wastewater Pumping Stations and Treatment Plants, Storm Water Pumping Stations, Water Transmission Lines, Desalination, Power, Steel, Cement, Paper & Pulp, Petrochemicals, Chemicals, Fertilizers and other process plants. Addressing global opportunity in the water sector. Listed.

10) Offshore Wind Renewables: KPEL - One of India’s largest BOP solutions provider for Wind Projects and Wind & Solar Hybrid Projects with target of 10+MW by 2030 by addressing EPCC, O&M and IPP segments. KP Group is India’s Leading Conglomerate in Renewable Energy Market. Listed

Date: 11 January 2025, Saturday
Time: 9.30 AM – 5.30 PM
Venue: The Ruby Hall, Sahara Star, Santacruz (East)

Registration Link: https://forms.gle/KvdvPPdXpecK5Faf9

2 Likes

Government is going to have big focus on defence sector in 2025. Exciting times for companies which have their own IP/tech in defence!!!

3 Likes

Can’t find ESDS & EMO Energy… Are they not listed…

Thanks & Regards

ESDS is not listed (traded in gray market) , so this might be an opportunity to know about the company.

Not able to attend but if you are going please provide summary post event for nogoers

Defsat 2025
“Achieving the appropriate level of Command and Control requires the seamless engagement of all systems, but identifying and integrating these systems remains a critical challenge. C4ISR systems, by their very nature, are software-intensive. For India to build its indigenous C4ISR capabilities, a strong foundation in software is essential. While India is a global software hub, young technocrats must be guided and mentored to navigate this specialised domain and contribute effectively to national defence innovation.” ~ Cmde S K Pujari, Chief Technolgy Advisor, C2C Advanced Systems

Disclaimer : Invested

3 Likes

Company has already set up office in USA and now actively hiring to build its technical team in Jersey area. Very interesting development.

Also their technical advisor, S K Pujari seems to be retired as “Additional General Director” in Indian Navy. Seems to be a highly technical person in various technologies like Radar etc

3 Likes

Here is an article on AI and autonomous weapon systems by Lt Gen P R Kumar (Retd)

1 Like

C2C Advanced System . A contribution from my side for understanding the business and its history. Got interested with the big marquee names in the RHP.

History :

C2C Advanced Systems started its root as dB Systems in 2006-2008

2008-2018:

dB Systems Inc. was set up in 2008 to take up retro fitting services for the Indian Navy ( Source : :: dB Systems Inc :: ) .

The company forged strategic partnerships with M/s Offshore Systems Limited (OSI) , Canada and MDA Corporation, Canada. which provided dB Systems Inc. with navigation and domain awareness and coastal surveillance products to meet requirements of these products for Indian Navy .

Company Verticals ( Source : :: dB Systems Inc ::)

  • Outsourced Repairs & Reverse Engineering : Outsourced Repairs and Reverse Engineering vertical aims to deploy the collective expertise of the group companies to resolve repair bottlenecks faced by customer and support obsolescence management through reverse engineering .

It means the company was basically sourcing repair products from its strategic Canadian partner OSI and then leveraging it for repair of Indian Navy and in some cases due to parts being obsolescent figuring out workarounds to repair the warships

  • Embedded Software Development vertical focuses on design and development of embedded software. . Activities like developing embedded software to replace legacy code, assist in understanding / refining / modifying deployed code, developing new software based systems to enhance the operational effectiveness of deployed forces etc. is taken up by the company.

This is the business which still remains with C2C and which is what the investors are excited about. The Combat Management Systems ( CMS ) can be considered as the heart and brain of the warship. This technology is only available with a handful ( less than 10 companies ) across the globe and it is critical as this piece of software which integrates with all the systems and sensors on a warship and acts as a control and command center which can decide the tactical moves the warship to monitor and defend itself from threats. These embedded systems can be considered the most coveted technology of a warship and its IP would be guarded secrets and could be the deemed as national assets which the handful of companies would own and would go at lengths to protect it

Brochure of db Systems products based on listing on Indiamart (https://www.indiamart.com/dbsystemsinc/db-systems-inc.pdf )

Now the question arises how did dbSystems a small company based out of Bangalore get skills to develop this critical piece of software ?

The answer could be found in the following article from 2015 ( Arming the Navy with hi-tech solutions - The Hindu BusinessLine )

Weapons and Electronics Systems Engineering Establishment (WESEE) , Indian Navy and DRDO engineers entered into joint development with a European CMS vendor and after working on the project for a decade, the first CMS was built in the early 1980s to 1990s.

db Systems co founder Commander Kuriyedath Ramesh was one of the founding members of the Indian Navy indigenous CMS system .

Another cofounder Commander LSS Narendra also left Indian Navy at around the same time to join dbSystems .

These 2 key person basically had the entire knowledge of the hardware sub systems , the integration and the software piece required to build an end 2 end CMS system . Whether Indian Navy software IP’s were compromised can be anyone guess but then by 2015 db Systems merely a 3 to 4 year old company claimed that they have the capability to design a complete CMS and already had a fully-built CMS in its repository and now are a part of one of the few companies across the globe to have their own CMS system.

Interesting thing to note , is that while the Company had a developed CMS system it has not been able to make in roads directly to supply to Indian Navy for an End2End system since the last 9 years and at best had to resort to supplying the subsystems to Tier-1 companies . Probable reasons could be either Indian Navy and WESEE did not trust dbSystems ( IP infringement ??) or could be their CMS was not upto date with Indian Navys requirement

2018-19 :

Feb 2018 : The 2 co-founders setup a the company C2C – DB Systems Private Limited which is now known as C2C Advanced Systems Limited.

2018 -19 : This was pivotal as this incorporation was just before the company received its first export order to supply end to end CMS to Marine Crest Technologies & T7 Marine SDN BHD for the Royal Malaysian Navy (RMN) for its 2 older warships KD Leiku and KD Jebat ( These 2 warships were commissioned in 1999 and were having CMS from Bae Systems and were due for retrofitting ) . RMN wanted to create it indigenous CMS just like Indian Navy , so this order to C2C was probably to create a customized version of CMS for Malaysian Navy and transfer part of the tech to RMN via Marine Crest Technologies .

The point to note that the C2C CMS was fitted on a 2 decade old warship with older technology and sensors and not on their latest warships so this was probably to test C2C CMS systems as well as get the technology transferred .

The CMS system was called as “Vibrant 01” system which replaced the “Nautis F” system (of BAE Systems origins) which had become obsolete after almost 25 years of operational service. Bae Systems had offered the Nautis 4 CMS to replace the current Nautis F CMS but it was deemed as too costly by RMN.

However , it seems that the company has struggled to get the orders from Malaysian Navy even after 6 years . This could be due to their first two warships are being refitted so probably things are progressing at a very slow pace . Refer this 2024 article which mentions some refits are still ongoing for KD Jebat .

This could mean for reasons unknown to us, even the CMS software adoption for Malaysian Navy is going on a snails pace.

2022-2023 : Getting Krishna (Sandy K Chandra) Chandra on Board as Managing Director and CEO . As per DRHP it wrongly mentions she instead of “He” ‘She holds a Bachelors degree in Social Sciences from the Madras University and a Masters degree in Business Administration from the Rutgers University, New Jersey, USA. She has 18 years of experience as a technology licensing specialist and has about 10 years’ experience as a digital design specialist’

Probably C2C founders Kuriyedath Ramesh & LSS Narendra realized that even though they have had mastered the tech capabilities of creating a CMS , probably selling and marketing their company was not their forte . Inspite of spending over a decade , their CMS was struggling acceptance against the Global competitors and Lakshmi Chandra was the boost they needed . As per Laksmi Chandra linkedin Bio , he is a Founder and Chairman “Secure Universe capital partners” a Private equity and investment bank focused on next generation technologies.

Surely he knows to sell stuff being a PE investor. So as the next step , born was the latest version of the company C2C Advanced Systems . Recipe for success add all the trending buzz words in the market and give C2C a New Brand Image

Step 1 : Change the logo and website

Old Logo
image

New Logo

Step 2 : Change Website

Old Website : C2C DB Systems | Home
New Website : https://c2c-as.com/

See the huge difference

Step 3 : Lets add all the buzz words to the Company

  1. Artificial Intelligence :
  2. Data Science and Analysis
  3. Industry 4.0 practises
  4. Lastly Command and Control Systems ( Ironically the company was built over a decade in C2C and sadly thats the last tile for the company because its not a buzz word known to investors) .

Some more buzz words
“Predictive Insights to Avoid Mishaps Before They Happen
Enhancing Business Productivity with Digital Automation
Digital Tools for Business Empowerment
Advanced Robotics and Automation
Smart ERP Solutions”

How many of these words fit the narrative that the company had built over the last 10 years as a defense organization.

Step 4 : Lets add more industries and buzzwords . We are not just serving Navy we have across industries

Step 5 : Lets add Products ( still figuring out )

Maybe I can help here with some of their upcoming and latest products courtesy India Mart again

C2C iCRM Software - i CRM Service Provider from Bengaluru - A competitor to Salesforce

C2C C2CProMGenius - A competitor to Service Now / Jira

C2C HRMSSoftware - i CRM Service Provider from Bengaluru - A competitor to Workday / SAP SuccessFactors

So , a company which was struggling for a decade in defense, now has a suite of products basically competing the best of the best SAAS based companies .

And what has C2C achieved during 2023 for its core CMS Project. The GUI for INS Vikrant was developed by C2C . So basically TASL got the contract for the CMS and the GUI possibly was built by C2C based on the LinkedIn comment

They have not been able to scale up on their Domestic Revenues as per the RHP .

2024 : Lets get the investors in before the IPO . The base is set , narrative is set , now lets promise some exponential returns to our pre ipo investors.

  • Preferential Issue of 5,12,839 Shares on December 18, 2023 of face value of ₹10 at a price of ₹136
  • Preferential Issue of 7,82,523 Shares on January 29, 2024 of face value of ₹10 at a price of ₹136
  • Preferential Issue of 8,35,850 Shares on February 13, 2024 of face value of ₹10 at a price of ₹ 160
  • Preferential Issue of 16,09,062 Shares on March 18, 2024 of face value of ₹10 at a price of ₹ 160

Transfer using Off Market Route from Promoter Group Shareholding

Conclusions

  1. C2C does have the end to end CMS capabilites for Warships . However , this business has failed to contribute in the past . Each End to End CMS would be atleast 30 cr revenues per warship. If the company can get even 30 warship orders in the next 3 years that vertical itself can generate over 900 cr in revenues. Defense is lumpy and some of the projects information could be classified , so this needs to be converted into revenues before jumping into conclusions and believing management commentary

  2. Change of Statutory Auditors for 4 times in the last 1 year is something which needs closure scrutiny especially after getting our new PE Investor and CEO Lakshmi Chandra on board

image

  1. Utilization of IPO proceeds . Yash Technologies is known for ERP implementations like SAP / Oracle and Analytics which are not software’s core to C2C’s defense business ? https://www.yash.com/ does not even mention Defense as an Industry so utilization of funds must be closely tracked

  2. Exponential Increase in Employee Cost and number of employees and data of employee and employee expenses does not align

image

image

  1. All buzz words are to fool the markets and the investors .

One more example when Commander LSS Narendra has skipped all the buzz words slides as if he is not confident going into the details . Start Video from Time Stamp 15:33 seconds

Again at TimeStamp 22:09 Commander LSS Narendra sees that Lakshmi Chandra has dropped the call and asks the moderator to get him added. The slide “Investment Rationale” was explained by Lakshmi Chandra. Ironically , the founder who has been since 2011 feels uncomfortable walking through the slides while a PE Investor cum CEO joined in the 2022 is responsible for explaning why we should invest in C2C Advanced systems .

  1. Revenue breakdown between India and Exports / Working Capital Cycle and Operating Cash Flows needs to be closely monitored . Considering they are more of a software and tech play, the Cash Flow from Operations must be closely tracked . Defense is lumpy but Domestic Revenues need to improve over coming quaters

Also while the narrative is Indian Defense opening up and huge opportunities in Shipbuilding industry , the Domestic Revenues need to be monitored closely

Existing Numbers from IPO Meet

image

  1. Hard questions needs to be asked to management about all the buzz words and why are they into unrelated businesses like CRM / Ticket Management / HRMS which do not make any sense. Also , giving an industry wise breakup as they are working not only in Defense but also in other industries will let us know what is the sales contribution of the different industries mentioned
19 Likes

Thanks, @Nabendu, for such a detailed write-up. I’ve gone through your message multiple times, but I couldn’t find anything that outright declares the company as a fraud. Yes, there are areas where we need clarification from the management, but nothing conclusively points to any fraudulent activity.

Employees often start companies in their area of expertise, and I see nothing wrong with that. The company was started in 2008. It took them 7 years to make the CMS, the system developed in 10 years by the Navy. It was not a 3-4 year old company. Also, it takes much less time when you know what you’re doing rather than figuring it out for the first time.

That’s a serious allegation, and it’s better to clarify it with the management. It’s also possible that the company was too small at the time, and the Navy preferred not to engage with it directly. Let’s ensure we have all the facts before concluding.

Nothing wrong with that—it’s a salesperson’s job to make things appealing and sellable. Now, let’s dive into the buzzwords.

You have accepted that the company have CMS capabilities.

CMS essentially revolves around gathering data from various sources, presenting it on a unified dashboard, and enabling informed actions or decisions based on it. It aligns closely with the domain of data science and analytics—the art of transforming raw data into actionable insights and meaningful interpretations.

No one is building AI from scratch like OpenAI or Google anymore. Most are leveraging open-source models like Llama and adapting them to their needs. It’s not groundbreaking (though still technical) — it’s about deploying existing tools effectively. If you can hire skilled talent to work on these models, supporting AI deployments becomes an easier process.

Absolutely, it’s important to get clarification from the management on this matter for a better understanding. Specifically, why there was a need to venture into unrelated fields. Was it a strategic decision or a fallback when other initiatives weren’t working? Also, what is the current contribution of this software in the topline?

It would be great if the management could organize a conference call to address these doubts. I will also try writing to the company. Let’s see if they will reply.

4 Likes

They are supplying products to Indian armed forces!!!

Writing such information that they are not supplying without doing proper research and checking facts either with the company or the customer (armed forces) is not a right thing to do.

Company faced significant cash crunch in 2020 during covid times when they were not able to do the testing of CMS on the Malaysian ships and getting qualification certificates. Thats why they raised funds in pre-IPO in 2023-24 when actually testing was finally completed to prepare for the future growth.

When a company is cash crunched then they don’t focus on marketing (website etc). These things come into picture as company prepares for the IPO listing once merchant bankers are assigned etc

Defence is a long gestation period of 7-8 years. Companies develop products, do multiple level of testing/approvals and then get orders. Both zentech/datapatterns had stagnant sales for 6-7 years before they reached inflection point and entered into a high growth phase. I believe C2C is currently at that inflection point in its journey.

Regarding the buzzwords the company is working on these technologies for quite sometime now. These buzzwords are not new. They are consistently working on these technologies since 2022-23

Regarding expansion in non defence industries, comoany has mentioned multiple times in pre-ipo listing concalls that they want to leverage their already established capabilities and look for opportunities in Industrial 4.0 field which is non-defence. They already have core capabilities so they want to leverage it to achieve higher growth.

Anyhow, we should get more clarity from the company during the FY25 concall.

Thanks

4 Likes

@fundoo @avneesh

Commander Kuriyedath Ramesh & Commander LSS Narendra joined in 2011 as per their own Linkedin so we can safely assume that they built the CMS systems in 3 to 4 years itself not 7-8 years .

Why did European partner take over a decade to transfer the technology to India ?? Try to answer that question in honesty and you will get the answer to your question .

Probably only a handful companies around the globe and even till date has the capability to build an end to end CMS system. Its been 10 years since they claimed they have end 2 end CMS system built and at least we know for sure they at sold a CMS to Malaysia between 2018-2019 . Its been over 6 years from that day and still they are figuring out how to sell to Indian Navy ? What stops Indian Navy from procuring from them ? Why did other companies like Data Patterns / Astra Microwave grow many folds but this struggled for existence needs to be questioned to the management when they had a product which makes them probably a monopolistic or oligopolistic player in India and also across the globe ? If Indian Navy was not open why havent they been able to sell their CMS systems across the globe ? They anyways were undercutting the MNCs so what is it that even after owning the tech for 10 long years they have publicly claimed selling only 2 end to end CMS system ?

we are talking about systems on warships not on our local computer we tend to talk so easily about embedding AI . They have to make real time decisions in seconds not that they can wait to send data to cloud and await for a response . They need AI inbuilt on device which works offline and we all know ondevice AI is just getting picked up in our local devices , leave thinking huge warships which will have the ondevice compute power to support large models. Apart from it , defense forces are paranoid with their data leaving their premises so cloud based AI or using Open AI would be the last thing defense forces would want to embed in their warships …

Also , I found an interesting video where someone has collated the discrepancies in RHP itself. Some of the points like different revenue figures even I had noticed ,but the guy has done a lot of research on the numbers and RHP side of things. Recommend you give it a watch as well to ask their management more questions

Keep the research going , ask the right questions and continue building the thread. I am not invested and I rather spend my limited time on the companies I own or plan to invest , but will be lurking around and hope they can turn things around.

I have nowhere claimed the company to be fraud but relying only on management when things have not worked out in the past , makes it a game of probability where my odds of winning seem way less. But like it goes in any probability game , if all the odds are against you and the company proves itself , it can be a huge wealth generator as well.

I like to play bets where my odds of winning are more , so this does not fit my current investment style but probing with the right questions will lead to more answers and help you build your conviction on the counter

3 Likes