Timing the markets are not really worth it

Investing in financial markets offers the potential for substantial wealth creation, but timing the market can be misleading. In this newsletter, we dive into the concept of timing the markets, examining its impact on index funds. We will also explore the benefits of adopting a long-term investment strategy and highlight the significance of capital protection in building a successful portfolio. Throughout our discussion, we will use real-world examples to illustrate the complexities and challenges of market timing.

Index funds have emerged as a popular investment option due to their simplicity and effectiveness. Market timing is not a critical factor in index funds since they aim to mirror the performance of a specific market index, such as the Nifty. Consider the past two decades, during which index funds have consistently delivered annualized returns close to 18%. This passive investment approach has allowed investors to generate substantial wealth over time, leveraging the power of compounding without the need to predict market movements. For instance, investing during the 2020 crash in the Nifty index would have led to significant gains in the subsequent years.

Taxation Benefits of Index Funds: A Path to Wealth Creation

One of the biggest advantages of index funds lies in their ability to provide tax arbitrage. Let’s consider a scenario where an individual or business earns 1 crore in profits and faces a substantial tax liability. By investing this money in an index fund, the investor can effectively earn around 18 lakhs annually without incurring additional tax burdens. Over time, the compounding effect can lead to exceptional wealth creation. On the other hand, individual stock investments, while potentially providing higher returns, also come with the risk of substantial losses. In fact, around 3000 companies listed today have delivered lower annualized returns than the Nifty, highlighting the advantages of including index funds in a diversified portfolio.

The Unpredictability of Markets: A Lesson from History

Market unpredictability is a reality that retail investors must confront. The global financial crisis of 2007-2008 serves as a stark reminder of how unforeseen events can dramatically impact markets. Attempting to time markets based on such uncertainties is an arduous task, even for seasoned investors. Instead, embracing a long-term investment approach enables investors to weather market fluctuations and capitalize on sustained economic growth.

FOMO and the Herd Mentality: Beware of Ill-Informed Decisions

The Fear of Missing Out (FOMO) and herd mentality can lead investors to make impulsive decisions based on tips or recommendations from acquaintances. The temptation to invest in “cheap” stocks can be strong, but such decisions often carry significant risks. In contrast, thorough research and informed decision-making are vital when considering investments, especially in lesser-known or penny stocks with limited available information.

Capital Protection: Balancing Risk and Reward

Investing is not just about earning high returns; it is also about safeguarding capital. Market timing may lead investors to wait for the perfect moment to enter or exit positions, potentially missing out on investment opportunities altogether. Emphasizing capital preservation and maintaining a diversified portfolio can mitigate risks and provide a sense of security, especially during challenging market conditions.

The pursuit of market timing in individual stocks remains a complex and risky endeavor. While some success stories exist, the average investor is better served by adopting a long-term investment approach and incorporating index funds into their portfolio. Such a strategy capitalizes on compounding and tax advantages while reducing exposure to market volatility. By avoiding impulsive decisions driven by FOMO and staying focused on informed, balanced investments, investors can build a path to long-term wealth creation and financial security.

1 Like

Cognitive Dissonance or Poor context?

Currently Bershire’s cash pile is more than 50% of their total portfolio AUM.

Note: this post was only meant to be thought provoking. For mere mortals like most of us timing the market is not worth the hassle.

5 Likes

Investing in the index funds is the easiest way to remain in the market. Often it entails great success also. For example, those who did not do anything during the covid times, did not sell during the sell-off, also made great money.
However, it goes against the Benjamin Graham’s Mr Market illustration. Once we accept that the markets could be crazy, it becomes difficult to remain cozily with a whimsical person.
When all the PSU stocks went dizzy, perhaps it was sensible to book some profit? My hypothesis was, how can an NBFC be valued so differently just because it had Railway in it!
Sometimes I have also bought and sold the entire portfolio, but then I realise I was merely helping the govt reach its target of direct tax collection.
Contrarily, real money is made in contra investing. Parag Parikh was one of its votaries. So are Howard Marks and Li Lu. But contra investing takes serious research, and courage of conviction.
So, there it is. If you feel you can really grasp the market cycles and deep dive into companies, you should go into contra investing. For the mere mortals, it is index investing.
PS: My daughters and wife bought 100 each of Waaree Renewable on 1st April 2025 at around ₹800. They have not bought any additional share in these stocks, nor sold even one share.
On the other hand, I had 1000 shares of Waaree Renewable in March '25 It shows the confusion in my mind that since then I have sold this and bought again several times.
Result is, their shares are 35% or so up, while I do not seem to have made any money.
While I can kick myself for the stupidity, this should be a lesson in discipline.

3 Likes