The Margin of safety I need in banking stocks

There are two types of companies according to the profits they make.1st type of companies which can make profits and have the ability to transfer that cash to the shareholders.2nd type of companies which make profits but can’t transfer all the cash to the shareholders.Its not like that, they can invest the cash and make more money for shareholders,but it’s the nature of business which does not allow the 2nd type of companies to throw cash to the shareholders.Yes I am talking about banking and NBFC businesses.What is a perfect business? A perfect compounding machine is that which invests back it’s profits to the business and makes more profit.First understand the lending business.The bank takes the raw material i.e. deposits from people and lend that money to people as loan and difference between deposit interest and loan interest is the profit for the bank.The bank may make Rs.10,000 crore profit in a year,but can’t share Rs.8,000 crores of profit to shareholders as dividend because it is having huge liability as deposits.So the profits of the banks are illusionary i.e. which you can see but can’t feel.Then how the shareholders will make money? The only way the shareholders will make huge money in a lending business is ,only by the appreciation in the stock price.The only way the stock price will go multi-fold is, if it’s earnings grows in handsome rate.So,there are two things you need to understand that ,1st the bank should be in its initial phase where the base profit is very low ,so that profits can mathematically rise in high % rate.2nd thing is ,the market cap should be of very low base,so that sufficient room is available in the market cap so that it can go up multi-fold. In other words its current stock price should not be discounting it’s potential future market cap.
The risk is that, what if market decides that from now onwards ,it will not give 30 PE multiple to a lending business…since the lending businesses do not have the ability to pay high dividends to the shareholders and decides to give 10 PE to such businesses.So in this scenario if u have bought the stock in the initial phase of the business ,then after 15 years, the earnings would have multi-fold and even if market gives low PE multiple ,still your can make multi-fold profit.
The perfect scenario for a bank to make super normal profit for its shareholders is that, when it becomes big enough and making Rs.40,000/- crores of yearly profit,then it should use this cash flow to decrease it’s deposit liability by Rs.40,000/- crore.But technically it is not possible.What HDFC Bank would tell to it’s depositors ? Is it going to tell it’s depositors to take back their money or reduce interest rates drastically.In both the cases the risk is that it’s deposits can collapse at instant.Another risk is that it can loose customer relationship and customers may not come for taking loans from the bank.So,the bank need to play the game 365 days irrespective of potential availability loan demand by quality customer.Because if it do not find sufficient good customers,then it’s margin will hurt,as it has to pay the interest to the depositors.So the bank need to keep hunting for customers.I just don’t like when companies hunt for growth.It just make them impatient and they tend to focus on outer score card rather than inner score card.When companies hunt for growth ,they are more obsessed with top line.They focus more on results rather than processes.But what I think, it is the process ,which creates result.So ,I am afraid of companies who are in hunt for growth.I like businesses ,where organic growth is there and hunting is not required.
So, for avoiding above risks,If I want to invest in a lending business,then I need the following margin of safety.

  • Organic growth opportunity should be there

  • The lending business should be growing i.e. the management should have the hunger for growth, but not hunting for growth.

  • The lending business should be at it’s initial phase and at low market cap as well i.e. its current stock price should not be discounting it’s potential future market cap.

  • The company should be more concerned with processes ,rather than sales volume.

3 Likes

Hunger for growth and hunting for growth…whats the difference between two?
If you catch banks and NBFC at very small and young stage, then collapse, fraud , bankruptcy or scam …these things are always possible…

1 Like

One of the most important factor I feel should be the honesty and integrity of the management above all else, that would be a great margin of safety. A young bank with good corp. governance would be a very good combination for making money.

1 Like

Hunger for growth is what…If there is scope of organic growth…then company…build the processes…and in turn processes produce result…And
Hunting for growth comes …When there is no organic growth left…Then the companies will try different things to show result…They may go for discount model,banks may go for sanctioning sub prime loans…This hunting may not be very risky for cash rich businesses like TCS,HUL …But if a leveraged business like bank and NBFC will do this …Then end result may be dangerous…When companies becomes so big ,then they can’t grow in high pace…What if HDFC bank plans to put 5000 branches per year…Or want to increase corporate lending 25k crore each year…I would call it as hunting for growth…And I am afraid of it…When ITC decided to go for hotel business…What you think …Is it hunting for growth…When TATAs go for airlines…Is it hunting for growth ?..It just does not make sense that … ITC and TATA are taking profit from high margin business to invest in low margin business…Just read 6 years of annual report of TATA investment corporation…You will notice that they r in hunting mode…Since they r unable create growth in existing businesses…

2 Likes

Yes …Good corporate governance and management integrity …these r the pre conditions before buying any stock…