NELCO Ltd. - Hidden Gem in Tata Group's Portfolio or Value Trap for satellite communication?

Stock Opportunities
1

Stock Details:
• Current Price: ₹1,033.35 (as of June 11, 2025)
• Market Cap: ₹2,362 Crores
• 52-Week High/Low: ₹1,502.75 / ₹706.95
• BSE/NSE: NELCO
• Sector: Satellite Communication & Technology

Company Overview
NELCO Limited, established in 1940, is a subsidiary of Tata Power and operates as a frontrunner in India’s satellite communication sector. The company is part of the $116 billion Tata Group and has evolved from being a revolutionary electronics company to becoming India’s leading VSAT (Very Small Aperture Terminal) service provider.
Key Business Segments:

  1. Satellite Communication (VSAT)—Primary revenue driver
  2. Enterprise WAN Solutions—Network connectivity for businesses
  3. Integrated Security & Surveillance Solutions—Government and defense applications
  4. Satcom Projects—Custom satellite communication projects

Financial Snapshot (Historical Performance Analysis)
Long-term Financial Trend (FY14-FY25):
• Revenue Growth: From ₹123 Cr (FY14) to ₹305 Cr (FY25) - 7.5% CAGR over 11 years
• Peak Performance: FY24 with ₹320 Cr revenue and ₹24 Cr net profit
• Recent Decline: FY25 revenue dropped to ₹305 Cr with profit halving to ₹10 Cr

Cyclical Performance Pattern:
• Turnaround Period (FY16-FY21): Revenue grew from ₹200 Cr to ₹260 Cr
• Golden Period (FY19-FY24): Strong profitability with margins expanding to 20%+
• Current Downturn (FY25): Revenue decline and margin compression

Profitability Evolution:
• FY14: Loss of ₹1 Cr, negative margins
• FY16-FY18: Modest profits of ₹2-6 Cr
• FY19-FY24: Strong profit growth from ₹14 Cr to ₹24 Cr
• FY25: Sharp decline to ₹10 Cr (58% drop)

Key Ratios (as of June 11, 2025):
• Market Cap: ₹2,362 Crores (based on current price of ₹1,033.35)
• P/E Ratio: 247.2x (based on FY25 EPS of ₹4.18)
• Book Value: ₹128 Cr (₹23 Cr equity + ₹105 Cr reserves)
• P/B Ratio: 18.5x (₹2,362 Cr market cap ÷ ₹128 Cr book value)
• Debt-to-Equity: 0.43x (₹55 Cr borrowings ÷ ₹128 Cr equity)
• ROCE: 14% (FY25) vs Peak of 26% (FY18)
• Asset Turnover: 1.06x (₹305 Cr revenue ÷ ₹287 Cr total assets)
Balance Sheet Strength:
• Total Assets: ₹287 Cr (steady growth from ₹164 Cr in FY13)
• Cash & Equivalents: Moderate levels with positive operating cash flows
• Debt Levels: Manageable at ₹55 Cr (19% of total assets)
• Working Capital: Negative cash conversion cycle indicates efficient management
Historical Performance Metrics:
• Revenue CAGR (11-year): 7.5% (FY14-FY25)
• ROCE Peak: 26% (FY18), Current: 14% (FY25)
• Dividend History: Consistent payout of 15-26% since FY19
• Promoter Holding: 50.1% (Tata Power)

Investment Thesis - The Bull Case

  1. Cyclical Business with Proven Turnaround Capability
    NELCO has demonstrated strong recovery capability in the past:
    • Historical Recovery: Turned around from losses in FY14 to consistent profits
    • Revenue Growth: Grew from ₹123 Cr (FY14) to peak of ₹320 Cr (FY24)
    • Margin Expansion: Operating margins improved from negative to 23% peak (FY20)
    • Dividend Track Record: Consistent dividend payments since FY19 (15-26% payout ratio)
    Strong Performance Period (FY19-FY24):
    • Revenue grew from ₹191 Cr to ₹320 Cr (67% growth)
    • Net profit increased from ₹14 Cr to ₹24 Cr (71% growth)
    • EPS growth from ₹5.31 to ₹10.37 (95% growth)
    • Maintained healthy operating margins of 19-23%
  2. Strategic Partnerships
    Telesat Partnership: NELCO has partnered with Canadian satellite giant Telesat to launch commercial satcom services. This partnership is expected to:
    • Provide affordable B2B satellite services
    • Compete with SpaceX, Amazon’s Kuiper, and OneWeb
    • Target the massive underserved Indian market (50% population still unconnected)
  3. Tata Group Advantage
    Being part of the Tata ecosystem provides:
    • Strong brand credibility with enterprise customers
    • Access to Tata Group’s extensive customer base
    • Financial backing and strategic support
    • Cross-selling opportunities across Tata companies
  4. Government and Defense Focus
    NELCO’s security and surveillance solutions cater to:
    • Defense applications (high-margin, sticky business)
    • Government infrastructure projects
    • Critical communication requirements
    • Border security and surveillance needs
  5. Strong Balance Sheet and Cash Management
    Financial Stability Indicators:
    • Debt Management: Moderate debt levels at ₹55 Cr (Debt-to-Equity: 0.43x)
    • Asset Base: Steady asset growth from ₹164 Cr (FY13) to ₹287 Cr (FY25)
    • Cash Generation: Consistent positive operating cash flows (₹20 Cr in FY25)
    • Working Capital Efficiency: Negative cash conversion cycle (-90 days in FY25)
    Operational Efficiency:
    • Inventory Management: 415 days inventory (high for service business, needs attention)
    • Receivables: 128 days collection period (reasonable for B2B business)
    • Payables: 632 days payment cycle (excellent supplier management)
    • Net Working Capital: Negative cycle provides cash flow advantage
    Return Metrics:
    • ROCE History: Peak of 26% (FY18), current 14% (still decent)
    • Asset Utilization: 1.06x asset turnover ratio
    • Capital Efficiency: Able to generate returns despite asset-light model

Investment Concerns - The Bear Case

  1. Sluggish Historical Growth
    • 5-year sales CAGR of only 6.75% raises questions about execution
    • Revenue of ₹305 crores is relatively small for a ₹2,232 crore market cap company
    • Growth trajectory has been disappointing despite being in a growth sector
  2. Deteriorating Financial Performance
    Revenue Decline: FY25 sales of ₹304.87 crores vs FY24 sales of ₹313.03 crores (2.6% decline)
    Profitability Concerns:
    • Net profit declined 57.7% from ₹22.50 crores (FY24) to ₹9.53 crores (FY25)
    • Operating margins compressed from 18-20% range to 9.54% in Q4 FY25
    • Q4 FY25 showed net loss of ₹4.08 crores vs profit of ₹6.10 crores in Q4 FY24
    Quarterly Volatility:
    • Sales range: ₹67.52 Cr to ₹83.24 Cr over past 13 quarters
    • Profit volatility: From ₹8.21 Cr (Q4 FY24) to -₹4.08 Cr (Q4 FY25)
    • EPS swings: From ₹2.70 to -₹1.79 within a year
    Operational Efficiency Issues:
    • Operating profit margins declining trend: 20.52% (Mar 2023) → 9.54% (Mar 2025)
    • Expense management challenges: Expenses not declining proportionally with sales
  3. Intense Competition
    • Facing competition from global giants like SpaceX’s Starlink
    • Amazon’s Kuiper and OneWeb are also entering the Indian market
    • Local players and telecom operators expanding satellite services
    • Price pressure from international competitors with deeper pockets
  4. Execution Risk
    • Telesat partnership success depends on execution capabilities
    • Technology evolution requires continuous investment
    • Regulatory changes could impact business model
  5. Working Capital and Efficiency Concerns
    Inventory Management Issues:
    • Inventory Days: Increased from 153 days (FY24) to 415 days (FY25) - 171% increase
    • Service Business Anomaly: High inventory levels unusual for satellite communication services
    • Cash Conversion Impact: Despite negative cycle, inventory buildup is concerning
    ROCE Deterioration:
    • Return Decline: ROCE dropped from 23% (FY24) to 14% (FY25)
    • Historical Peak: 26% ROCE in FY18, current levels show declining efficiency
    • Asset Utilization: Revenue per asset declining despite asset base growth
    Operational Metrics:
    • Debtor Days: Increased from 97 days (FY24) to 128 days (FY25)
    • Collection Efficiency: Deteriorating customer payment cycles
    • Asset Productivity: Lower revenue generation per rupee of assets deployed

Recent Developments & Catalysts
Positive Catalysts:

  1. Stock Performance: NELCO gained 31% in 2024, outperforming many Tata Group stocks
  2. Regulatory Easing: Government considering relaxation of satellite communication regulations
  3. Partnership Progress: Telesat-NELCO services expected to launch commercially
  4. Market Recognition: Increasing focus on satellite communication stocks
    Potential Risks:
  5. Delayed Partnerships: Any delays in Telesat partnership could impact growth
  6. Regulatory Uncertainty: Changes in satellite communication policies
  7. Technology Disruption: Rapid technological changes in satellite industry
  8. Margin Pressure: Competition leading to pricing pressure

Peer Comparison & Competitive Positioning
Strengths vs Competitors:
• Established player with 80+ years of heritage
• Strong relationships with government and defense
• Part of trusted Tata brand
• Deep understanding of Indian market requirements
Weaknesses vs Competitors:
• Smaller scale compared to global players
• Limited financial resources vs SpaceX/Amazon
• Slower growth compared to new-age satellite companies
• Technology gap with cutting-edge satellite operators

Management & Corporate Governance
Positives:
• Part of Tata Group with strong governance standards
• Professional management with industry experience
• Clear strategic direction towards satellite communication focus
• Regular communication with stakeholders
Areas to Watch:
• Execution of growth strategy
• Capital allocation decisions
• Partnership management
• Technology investments

Valuation Analysis
Current Metrics:
• P/E Ratio: 247.2x (based on FY25 EPS of ₹4.18)
• P/B Ratio: 18.5x (₹2,362 Cr market cap ÷ ₹128 Cr book value)
• Market Cap/Revenue: 7.7x (based on FY25 revenue of ₹305 Cr)
• ROCE: 14% (FY25) vs historical peak of 26%
• Debt-to-Equity: 0.43x (manageable debt levels)
• Asset Turnover: 1.06x (revenue ÷ total assets)
• Cash Conversion Cycle: -90 days (working capital advantage)
Fair Value Assessment: Based on historical performance and current metrics:
Historical Valuation Context:
• During profitable years (FY19-FY24), stock likely traded at 100-150x P/E
• Peak EPS of ₹10.37 (FY24) suggests fair value range of ₹1,000-1,500
• Current EPS of ₹4.18 suggests fair value range of ₹400-650
Scenario Analysis:
• Recovery Scenario: If EPS returns to ₹8-10 range, stock could justify ₹800-1,500
• Continued Decline: If EPS falls to ₹2-3 range, fair value drops to ₹200-450
• Current Trading: At ₹1,033, stock is pricing in full recovery to peak performance
For current valuations to be justified, NELCO would need to demonstrate:
• Immediate return to FY24 profitability levels (₹24 Cr profit)
• Revenue growth acceleration back to ₹320+ Cr levels
• Operating margin expansion back to 19-20% range
• Successful execution of strategic initiatives

Key Monitoring Points
Financial Health Indicators:

  1. Quarterly Revenue Trends: Watch for recovery from current ₹67-83 Cr quarterly range
  2. Operating Margin Recovery: Monitor improvement from current 14% back to 19-23% range
  3. Inventory Management: Critical to watch 415-day inventory cycle normalization
  4. ROCE Improvement: Track return to historical 20-26% range
  5. Cash Flow Sustainability: Ensure continued positive operating cash flows

Conclusion
NELCO presents a classic case of a promising theme with challenging execution. While the satellite communication opportunity is real and growing, the company’s historical performance and current valuation present significant risks.
The Tata Group connection provides credibility and resources, but it doesn’t guarantee success in an increasingly competitive market. The stock appears to be pricing in perfection, leaving little room for disappointment.

Disc: Invested hence biased & critical. Not a buy/sell recommendation. Post only for learning purposes.

2 Likes
2

Satellite com ecosystem is still very nascent in India and we do not know how things going to evolve. For example, instead of competing with spacex, Nelco has gone into a partnership with them as well and its not just Nelco…even Airtel and Jio have partnered witj Spacex. Interestingly, Airtel has its own satellite system via OneWeb still it chose to partnership with Spacex.

Reliance and Tata do not own satellites yet. In long run, will ownership of LEO satellites matter, I do not know…Also, Airtel and Jio will have more marketing and crossselling offerings to likes of Spacex. What can Nelco provide them which they dont already have is the thing to focus on…and that can be probaby some technology areas in Sat Com where these Satellite owners and broadband providers do not want to focus on and leave that B2B opportunity to likes of Nelco…
Now is that opportunity real, scalable and how big it is…I do not know…

Also, Tata group’s vision of this space and how they would want to position them in this big opportunity may evolve and would be good to understand and track…(Like initially they planned to apply for full fledged licence for broadband, if I am not wrong, but later didnt and chose only the in-flight Wifi option for now…)

Would be good to know insights on this market evolution amd Sat Com ecosystem development & related opportunities from any expert here…

Disc: Invested hence biased & critical. Not a buy/sell recommendation. Post only for learning purposes. I can be wrong in all my assessments. Not eligible for any advice.

2 Likes
3

On the Partnership vs Competition Paradox:
There is no doubt that this space is getting incresingly complex. The Airtel-OneWeb-Starlink tringle is agreat example of how even satellite companies are exploring multiple ties-ups insted of going solo. In away, that’s actully good news for NELCO. It opens the door for them to position themeselves as a “connectivity aggregator” not jus another services provider, but someone who brings diffrent network together for businesses that can’t afford to rely on a single source.

Where NELCO Might Stand Out:
From what I’ve seen so far, NELCO seems to have a few edges that differentiate it:

  • They focus on niche B2B solutions – things like defense, enterprise WANs, and remote surveillance – areas where large telcos often prefer to partner instead of building it all in-house.

  • They have experience navigating India’s regulatory maze, which is no small feat in the satellite space.

  • They seem strong on system integration – offering clients redundancy and uptime by combining multiple satellite networks.

  • And they bring deep vertical expertise, which telcos or global satellite players might not prioritise for a relatively small market.

The Tata Group Angle:
It’s interesting to see Tata moving away from the full broadband license and instead focusing on in-flight Wi-Fi first. Feels like a cautious, smart move – test the waters in a smaller, less crowded space before going all in.

What’s Still Unclear:
The big question remains – how big is the enterprise satellite services market in India?
Government and defence demand seems steady, but is it scalable? Or are we looking at a niche market that might eventually get squeezed between large satellite operators and telecom giants, turning it into a low-margin game?

Company’s Latest Annual Reports Findings:
Nelco’s renewed purpose is to create a ubiquitously connected world, empowering businesses and communities and enabling nation-building endeavours. Its reimagined vision is to be a globally trusted and most preferred communication solutions partner, weaving innovative and cutting-edge Satcom technologies, to unlock potential for its customers and stakeholders. This vision represents not just aspirations but a strategic direction for substantial growth in the coming years within an increasingly connected world.
Nelco aims to position itself in the significant opportunity presented by the evolving Indian satellite communication (Satcom) industry. The industry is undergoing a paradigm shift driven by progressive policy reforms, increased private sector participation, and rapid technological advancements. India is seen as a crucial growth market, where satellite networks are becoming a critical backbone for inclusive connectivity, especially given that a significant portion of the country remains unconnected.
Nelco’s strategy to capitalise on this opportunity involves several key pillars:

  • Leveraging Cutting-Edge Satcom Technologies: Nelco intends to adopt Satcom technologies best suited for customer applications, including GSO (Geostationary Orbit) and NGSO (Non-Geostationary Orbit) networks, software-defined satellites, and new-age electronics as they become available. The company is actively engaged with global satellite operators and technology manufacturers to evaluate the latest technologies and solutions.

  • Customised Products and Services: The company focuses on creating customised products and services through strategic partnerships in multiple technologies. Nelco already has partnerships with global players and plans to continue forming more alliances to enhance its offerings and reach. They offer hybrid multi-modal solutions along with value-added services for key sectors.

  • Market Expansion and Innovation Leadership: Nelco aims for market expansion across various segments, continuously innovating its portfolio with industry-tailored and indigenous solutions, and exploring new verticals. This includes strengthening its presence in enterprise, government, and In-Flight & Maritime Connectivity (IFMC) segments. The company is also pioneering multi-modal next-gen Satcom solutions adapted to India’s unique connectivity needs, backed by necessary licenses and a commitment to secure, scalable connectivity.

  • Infrastructure and Technology Investment: The company aligns infrastructure investments with long-term trends and deploys cutting-edge technologies for satellite gateways. Nelco continuously evaluates opportunities for investment and augmentation of its technology, satellite network capabilities, and ground infrastructure. Efforts are also being made towards technology absorption, adaptation, and innovation, building expertise in various digital technologies for improved quality of service and customer experience.

  • Policy Advocacy: Nelco strengthens its policy advocacy by actively engaging with regulatory bodies and industry associations. For example, Nelco’s Managing Director & CEO serves as the Chairperson of the Satcom Committee for the Broadband India Forum (BIF). The company proactively engages with industry bodies and regulatory authorities to minimise any potential adverse impact from regulatory changes.

  • Operational Efficiency and Digital Transformation: Nelco is leveraging digital tools, data analytics, and automation to improve customer responsiveness, streamline operations, and develop next-generation Satcom solutions.

  • The company believes its focus on hybrid multi-modal solutions, sector-specific customised offerings, infrastructure readiness, and strategic global alliances positions it well to capitalise on India’s Satcom growth story. Nelco currently holds an estimated 40% share of the Satcom industry’s revenue and has demonstrated agility in creating new businesses and solutions. Its strategic approach also includes efforts to build resilience through access to multiple satellites, teleport redundancy, and hybrid networks to mitigate infrastructure risks.

Would love to hear thoughts from others tracking this space especially any data or insights on the actual market size, or how recent policy changes might be shaping the competitive landscape.

2 Likes
4

Lot of information with lot of repeatation…Your insight is highly generalized. Yet, good to look at sector which promises future forward looking in defence. Future wars will be highly supported by space technology.
My suggestion is to look at investor calls of last 4-6 quaters, if it held and details available. What management has said in previous calls and subsequent actual achievement.
This way we can look at future of NELCO.

2 Likes
5

Agree this is the big question.

Do you have any thoughts on ownership of Nelco not directly by Tata Sons but via Tata Power? When Tata consumer was envisaged from erstwhile Tata Global, Tata Sampann was carved out from Tata Chemicals and few other subsidiaries and cross-holdings were streamlined…all this showed the vision, seriousness of Tata group for FMCG and provided the right base for the next level growth of Tata Consumer. A Tata Power ownership and existence of another Tata group company in the overall B2B telecom space - Tata Communications, may leave multiple possibilities ahead…

2 Likes
6

Thanks for the feedback! You’re right space tech will be key in defense going forward.
On investor communication: NELCO doesn’t hold quarterly conference calls. They only share updates via annual reports and exchange filings, which limits visibility on execution. Hopefully, as they scale, this improves.
Appreciate the discussion let’s keep tracking this space.

1 Like
7

If investor calls are not held, not possible to track and hence can not be fully analysed, just on annual results and reports. Stock exchange is highly dynamic financial markets.

3 Likes
8

The Tata Power aspect I viewed it similarly. It seems like a strategic move rather than a random one. Perhaps they are testing a different approach this time. What also tinkers in my mind is involvement at Tata Power. He’s known for long-term thinking, so it makes me wonder if there’s a deeper strategy linking power and connectivity. The Tata Comm overlap is unusual too. They rarely let group companies overlap like this unless there’s a bigger plan brewing maybe consolidation or carving out segments. Feels like Tata is keeping options open and hasn’t revealed its full hand

1 Like
9

That’s drawback in this.

1 Like
10

Nelco granted 10-year national VSAT Virtual Network Operator license by Indian DoT.
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachLive/2bef554e-184f-4240-8c74-1c37dd2c1846.pdf

1 Like