IGI India A Global Leader in Diamond Certification with Unmatched Market Presence

IGI India A Global Leader in Diamond Certification

1. Industry Overview

  • Sector: Gemmology and Certification Services

Global Jewellery Market

:bulb:The total size of the global jewelry market as of 2024, INR 26,600 billion equivalent to approximately USD 320 billion. China, India, and USA Is leading consumer market

Men’s Jewelry Market: Men’s jewelry made up 10% of the global jewelry market in 2023, worth about INR 2,900 billion (USD 35 billion). Common items include cufflinks, gold chains, necklaces, and rings. This market is expected to grow by 8% each year, reaching INR 4,100 billion (USD 50 billion) by 2028.

New Technology in Jewelry: The jewelry industry is using modern technology to improve how jewelry is made and sold:

  • Computer design tools help create detailed jewelry designs
  • Laser machines make precise engravings
  • 3D printers can make complex jewelry pieces
  • Virtual try-on features let shoppers see how jewelry looks on them when shopping online

Consumption of Jewellery by Top Countries

Indian Jewellery Market Size

image

India’s Jewellery Market Overview

The Indian jewellery market reached INR 5,300 billion (USD 64 billion) in FY 2023. During the COVID lockdowns, jewellery store traffic declined significantly as weddings—the primary driver of jewellery demand in India—were postponed. This led to fewer celebratory and gift purchases, causing the market to contract by approximately 28% to INR 3,400 billion (USD 41 billion) in FY 2020. The market subsequently rebounded after the pandemic, fuelled by pent-up consumer demand, and grew at a 16% CAGR to reach INR 5,300 billion (USD 64 billion) in FY 2023.
Gold dominates India’s jewellery market with an 82% share (INR 4,300 billion) in FY 2023, down from 87% in FY 2019, and is expected to decline to 70-75% by FY 2028. Diamond-studded jewellery has grown from 7% in FY 2019 to 15% (INR 780 billion) in FY 2023, with projected 20% CAGR through FY 2028. The major growth for this fast growth of diamond-studded jewellery.

  1. Rising discretionary incomes: Growing middle-class disposable income drives jewelry purchases as both fashion items and investments.
  2. Young urban consumers: Jewelry buying extends beyond traditional occasions, with younger buyers following global trends and purchasing diamonds for daily wear.
  3. Working women shoppers: Financially independent women are key decision-makers in jewelry purchases, driving demand for both everyday and special occasion pieces.
  4. Western fashion influence: Growing preference for diamond-studded jewelry (~18% market share in 2023, expected 25-30% by 2028) reflects changing style preferences and increased luxury consumption.

2. Diamond Market

Diamonds come in 2 types: natural and lab-grown (LGDs). Both share identical physical, chemical, and optical properties, including brilliance, fire, and durability. The key difference is origin - natural diamonds form over millions of years underground, while LGDs are created in labs within weeks.

Natural diamonds (NDs) follow a value chain with three major stages from exploration to retail, involving multiple stakeholders.

Value chain of Natural Diamond-studded Jewelry

The process from rough diamond to polished diamond How diamonds are made Link https://www.igi.org/consumer-education/learn-today/natural-diamonds/

  • Upstream
    The upstream stage begins with diamond exploration and mine development. Companies search for viable diamond deposits through geological surveys, drilling, and feasibility studies. Once identified, they invest in infrastructure and equipment to establish mining operations. As of 2023, global industrial diamond reserves were approximately 1,700 million carats according to the US Geological Survey. Russia, Botswana, and Canada Hold 68% of total natural diamond mining in FY 2022.

Global Natural Rough Diamond Production

Gems as Rough

  • Midstream
    Diamond cutting involves a meticulous process. Rough diamonds are analyzed for their characteristics to determine the optimal cutting plan. Advanced technology aids in creating precise digital blueprints. Skilled lapidaries then cut and polish the diamonds to maximize their beauty and value. Approximately half of the rough diamonds are used for industrial purposes, while the other half is used for jewelry. The cutting and polishing process results in a significant weight loss of around 50%.
  1. Total Rough Diamond Production: This is the starting point, The total amount of rough diamonds mined.
  2. Industrial Rough Diamonds: About half of the rough diamonds are not suitable for jewelry. These are used for industrial purposes like cutting tools and drilling bits.
  3. Jewelry-grade Rough Diamonds: The other half is considered good enough for jewelry.
  4. Waste (Cutting & Polishing): When cutting and polishing rough diamonds, a lot of material is lost as waste. This is shown as a significant reduction in the amount of diamonds.
  5. Total Polished Diamonds: The final result is the total number of polished diamonds that can be used for jewelry. This is much smaller than the original amount of rough diamonds due to the waste generated during the cutting and polishing process.

Gems as POLISHED then these are sold to consumers

Polished diamonds are checked and certified by expert labs. They look at things like color, clarity, cut, size, and whether the diamond is natural or lab-made. This certification happens before diamonds are sold.

:bulb:India is the leading importer of rough diamonds, contributing to 42% of overall rough diamond imports in FY 2023. UAE and EU are the next leading importer of rough diamonds.

:bulb:India is the world’s largest centre for cutting and polishing diamonds, accounting for ~95% of the world’s total polished diamonds in volume terms in FY 2023. In India, Surat is the primary hub of cutting and polishing diamonds, contributing to more than 90% of India’s total volume in FY 2023.

  • Downstream
    Retail sales are the next step in the diamond value chain, where jewelry retailers sell to customers worldwide. The market is highly diverse, with many different store formats. Since the pandemic, online shopping has become a popular choice for buying diamonds because it offers a wide variety and more options. While the USA is the biggest market for diamonds, demand in Asia is growing faster.
  • The US is the biggest buyer of natural diamonds, accounting for over half of all diamond purchases. China and India are the next largest markets, but they are less organized than the US market. In the US, most diamonds are sold through well-known brands and stores, while in China and India, a larger portion is sold through less formal channels.
  • China, India, and the US are the biggest buyers of diamond jewelry in the world, together making up about 77% of the total market. The US is the biggest buyer, spending around 57 billion US dollars on diamond jewelry. Both China and India have seen a big increase in diamond jewelry purchases, growing at a rate of over 20% per year. China now spends around 13.5 billion US dollars and India spends around 9 billion US dollars on diamond jewelry.

Natural Diamond Jewelry - Market Structure

image

Pricing of LGD vs Natural Diamonds

India is not only a major consumer of diamond jewelry but also plays a pivotal role in the global value chain for both natural and lab-grown diamonds. In FY 2022, India ranked as the sixth-largest exporter of jewelry and loose stones.

India’s Role in Lab-Grown Diamonds

  • India is the second-largest producer of rough lab-grown diamonds contributing ~35% of global LGD production in FY 2023.
  • Top Exporter India ranked first in LGD exports in FY 2022, with a 29% global export share.
    • Skilled Labor: A large pool of highly skilled artisans, leveraging generational expertise in cutting, polishing, and jewelry-making, at competitive costs.
    • World-Class Infrastructure: Specialized hubs like Surat, Mumbai, and Jaipur, equipped with advanced technology, support efficient diamond processing.
    • The Indian government is actively supporting the diamond industry. They’ve built a large diamond trading center in Surat called the Surat Diamond Bourse. They’ve also introduced new rules to make it easier to trade rough diamonds in India. Additionally, the government is investing in research on lab-grown diamonds and has reduced taxes on importing materials and certifying diamonds. These measures aim to boost the diamond industry, create jobs.

Core Business & Market Overview IGI India’s Leading Role in Diamond Certification and Grading

Diamond certification involves a detailed process by independent labs, assessing key factors such as weight, color, clarity, cut, and fluorescence. The 4Cs (Carat Weight, Color, Clarity, and Cut) provide objective grading standards. Certification includes additional tests like laser inscription and origin identification.

Example of Color Grading Scale used for Diamond Certification

  • D-F: Colorless - These diamonds are extremely rare and valuable, with no visible color.
  • G-J: Near Colorless - These diamonds may show a slight hint of color, but it is usually invisible to the untrained eye. They offer good value.
  • K-M: Faint Yellow - These diamonds show a faint yellow or brownish hue, and their color may be noticeable to the naked eye.
  • N-R: Light Yellow - Noticeable yellow or brown tones are visible in these diamonds.
  • S-Z: Very Light Yellow to Yellow - These diamonds have strong color and are the least valuable.

The Grading Process Link - https://www.igi.org/grading-process/

Cut Grading

Certification Reports

  • A diamond certification report is an official document detailing a diamond’s quality based on standardized grading systems.
  • The report includes the diamond’s carat weight, color grade, clarity grade, cut grade, and fluorescence, along with diagrams and laser inscriptions for identification.
  • It provides buyers with confidence in the diamond’s authenticity and quality, and is crucial for pricing and resale value.

Click here To see Report’s By IGI

In 2023, around 33 million carats of diamonds were produced globally, with natural diamonds mostly smaller in size, while lab-grown diamonds (LGDs) are produced in larger sizes. Certification penetration is higher for LGDs (~70%) compared to natural diamonds (~65%).

IGI holds a significant global market share in certification, with 42% of studded jewelry certifications and 33% overall. The certification market studded jewelry valued at INR 46-54 billion in 2023, expected to grow at a CAGR of 9-13% till 2028, with LGD certification growing the fastest at ~22%. India remains a key hub for certification, contributing 60-70% of global certifications in 2023.

Drivers for Growth of Loose Stones and Studded Jewelry Certification

  1. Increasing Consumer Awareness Education campaigns, media coverage, and industry partnerships have raised awareness about certification.
  2. Surge in Lab-Grown Diamond (LGD) 70% of LGDs are certified globally in 2023, and the demand for LGDs is expected to drive certification rates to 85% by 2028.
  3. Smaller Diamonds Certification is expanding due to the increasing risk of adulteration and the need for authenticity.
  4. Growth of the Second-Hand Diamond With the rise of pre-owned jewelry sales, certification assures provenance and quality, making it essential for vintage and rare pieces.

Competitive Advantage of the Certification Market

The loose stones and studded jewelry certification market is dominated by a few players, including IGI, GIA, and HRD Antwerp, due to high barriers to entry such as reputation, high set-up costs, and specialized expertise.

  • Leading players partnerships with retailers, this strengthening their market position.
  • Certification from recognized bodies like ISO ensures quality and independence.

IGI’s Position

:bulb:IGI holds a 33% global market share in diamond, studded jewelry, and colored stones certifications. It commands 42% of studded jewelry certifications and 65% of LGD certifications globally in 2023.

:bulb:IGI has the largest number of laboratories and schools globally, with a presence in 10+ countries, establishing it as a leader in the certification industry.

Competitor Lab & schools

Global Company’s in the Diamond Certification Industry

  1. International Gemological Institute (IGI)
  2. Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
  3. Gemological Science International (GSI)
  4. Hoge Raad Voor Diamant (HRD)
  5. Solitaire Gemmological Laboratories (SGL)

:bulb:The USA and Hong Kong are significant consumers, while India, the UAE, Türkiye, and Belgium are central to diamond manufacturing and trading, with cities like Surat, Dubai, Istanbul, and Antwerp serving as hubs.

The core services offered by IGI and its peers include grading for natural diamonds, lab-grown diamonds, and coloured stones, based on the 4Cs (cut, clarity, color, and carat weight). IGI provides additional services such as laser inscriptions, origin reports, quality audits, and damage analysis.


3. Business Overview

  • Core Operations: Certification and accreditation services for diamonds (natural and lab-grown), studded jewelry, and colored stones. This highlights that your primary expertise lies in evaluating and authenticating the quality and characteristics of these precious items.
  • Competitive Advantages:
    • Established global brand presence.
    • Technological edge in gem certification.
  1. International Gemmological Institute (IGI) is a leading global provider of certification and accreditation services for diamonds, colored gemstones, and jewelry.
  • Diamond Certification
  • Colored Gemstone Certification like rubies, sapphires, and emeralds.
  • Jewelry Certification
  • Laboratory-Grown Diamond Certification
  • Educational Programs

Revenue Sources

  • Certification/Accreditation Services Main revenue source.
  • Education: Revenue generated through IGI Schools of Gemology, indicating a focus on training and knowledge dissemination within the gemological field.
  • Traded Goods: Revenue from selling Dcheck System equipment, suggesting a technological aspect to your business that provides tools or solutions for your customers.

Diamond Reports

  • Report offer specialized reports tailored to the type of diamond
    • Natural Diamond Report
    • Laboratory Grown Diamond Report
  • Report provide crucial information for assessing a diamond’s value
    • Origin: Clearly identifies whether the diamond is natural or lab-grown.
    • 4Cs: Documents all aspects of the diamond’s 4Cs (carat, cut, color, clarity), which are the globally recognized standards for evaluating diamond quality.

Grading and Reporting Processes

1. Fancy-Shaped Diamond Grading

  • Polish and Symmetry Grading
  • Proportions Qualifications
  • Shape-Specific Requirements

2. Jewelry Reports

  • Details of mounted stones (e.g., shape, measurements, 4Cs for diamonds, or gemological details for colored stones).
  • Precious metal content and purity stamps.
  • High-quality photos showing craftsmanship and mounting details.

3. Co-Branded Reports

  • Certification fees are shared with the collaborating brand/retailer as commissions.

Customer Segments

  1. Upstream Market
    • Customers: Lab-grown diamond growers and natural diamond wholesalers.
    • Purpose: Certification of polished diamonds before selling to jewelry manufacturers or retailers.
  2. Manufacturing Market
    • Customers: Jewelry manufacturers and brands.
    • Purpose: Certification of diamond or colored stone jewelry before retail sales.
  3. Downstream Market
    • Customers: End-consumers, either directly (walk-ins) or indirectly through retailers.
    • Purpose: B2C jewelry certification services upon request.

Notable Customers and Achievements

  • Clients: Includes diamond growers like Kira Diam, jewelry firms such as Morellato, and international luxury brands.
  • Significant Milestone

:bulb:Jewelry for the Ram Lalla idol at the Ram Mandir temple in Ayodhya (January 2024).

:bulb: The world’s largest lab-grown diamond, ‘Celebration of India’ (75.33 carats), certified in March 2024.


4. Financial Highlights

Financial Performance Comparison (₹ In Million)

Metric 3 Months Ended March 31, 2024 Year Ended December 31, 2023 Year Ended December 31, 2022 Year Ended December 31, 2021 CAGR (FY2021-FY2023)
Revenue 2,780.38 8,980.14 6,385.28 4,909.94 32.32%
EBITDA 1,734.37 4,960.02 4,501.18 3,351.82 36.76%
EBITDA Margin 62.38% 55.23% 70.49% 68.27% 3.36%
PBT 1,710.89 4,554.31 4,437.78 3,293.61 37.11%
PBT Margin 61.53% 50.72% 69.50% 67.08% 3.62%
PAT 1,260.76 3,308.48 3,247.38 2,417.58 37.59%
PAT Margin 45.34% 36.84% 50.86% 47.03% 3.98%

My take on Financial Performance

  • Strong Revenue Growth company has consistently demonstrated strong revenue growth over the years, driven by increased demand for its services.
  • Improved Profitability company has significantly improved its profitability margins, indicating efficient operations and cost control.
  • Company maintains a healthy financial position with positive net working capital and a strong balance sheet.

Segmental Revenue Breakdown

Revenue Source Three-Month Period Ended March 31, 2024 % of Total Revenue (Q1 2024) Calendar Year 2023 FY 2023 Calendar Year 2022 FY 2022 Calendar Year 2021 FY 2021 CAGR (CY2021-CY2023)
Certification Services 99.05% 6,206.82 97.21% 4,777.44 97.30% 3,574.30 98.01% 31.78%
Natural Diamonds 393.49 18.82% 1,224.16 19.45% 1,221.39 25.23% 1,183.51 32.45% 1.70%
Laboratory Grown Diamonds 1,260.41 60.28% 3,338.66 53.03% 2,049.88 42.35% 1,286.73 35.28% 61.08%
Studded Jewelry & Colored Stones 417.36 19.95% 1,644.00 25.75% 1,506.17 31.12% 1,104.06 30.27% 22.03%
Education 11.83 0.57% 53.59 0.84% 38.73 0.79% 24.71 0.68% 47.28%
Others 7.98 0.38% 124.87 1.95% 93.77 1.91% 47.90 1.31% 61.46%
Total Revenue from Operations 2,091.07 100.00% 6,385.28 100.00% 4,909.94 100.00% 3,646.91 100.00% 32.32%

5. Key Risks and Data Overview

  1. Dependence on Global Gemstone Market Demand
    • IGIL’s business depends on the continuous demand for gemological certification services, which is influenced by fluctuations in the global demand for gemstones and jewelry.
  2. Impact of Economic Downturns
    • Economic slowdowns or downturns can negatively affect the demand for luxury goods, including certified gemstones and jewelry, leading to reduced business volumes.
  3. Competition from Unorganized Sector
    • The unorganized gem certification sector may offer lower-cost alternatives, which could challenge IGIL’s market share, especially in price-sensitive markets.
  4. Changes in Regulatory Environment
    • Any changes in government regulations or policies affecting the gemological certification industry or financial regulations could negatively impact the business.
  5. Technological Risk
    • IGIL relies on advanced technology for gemological testing and certification. Any disruptions, technological failures, or inability to keep up with innovation could hinder its ability to compete.
  6. Dependence on Key Management
    • The loss of key management personnel, including the CEO or CFO, could disrupt operations and hinder the company’s strategic plans.
Revenue from Top Customers March 31, 2024 FY 2023 FY 2022 FY 2021
Top 10 ₹1,023.66 (48.95%) ₹2,597.92 (40.69%) ₹1,666.23 (33.94%) ₹861.88 (23.63%)
Top 15 ₹1,155.27 (55.25%) ₹2,966.52 (46.46%) ₹1,914.06 (38.98%) ₹1,058.01 (29.01%)

Revenue of Certification Business (in millions ₹)

Region Q1 2024 2023 2022 2021
Gujarat 1,099.62 (53.09%) 2,849.51 (45.91%) 1,942.76 (40.67%) 1,145.43 (32.05%)
Maharashtra 807.04 (38.96%) 2,688.99 (43.32%) 2,227.82 (46.63%) 1,959.38 (54.82%)
Rest of India 160.98 (7.77%) 645.05 (10.39%) 605.62 (12.68%) 469.49 (13.14%)
Total 2,071.26 6,206.82 4,777.44 3,574.30

Key observations from the data

  • Gujarat and Maharashtra consistently account for over 90% of the total revenue
  • Total revenue has shown growth year over year

6. Management and Governance

  • Key Personnel:

    • Managing Director & CEO: Tehmasp Nariman Printer
    • CFO: Easwar Subramanian Iyer
    • Company Secretary: Hardik Desai
  • Board Composition: The Board currently consists of six directors: one Executive Director, three Non-Executive (Nominee) Directors, and two Independent Directors.

  • Board Size: The company’s Articles of Association stipulate a minimum of three and a maximum of fifteen directors.

  1. Bimal Tanna: Chairman and Independent Director. He is a chartered accountant with extensive experience, having worked with PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) for over two decades.
  2. Tehmasp Nariman Printer: Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer. He has been with the company for over 25 years and possesses deep expertise in the diamond industry. He holds a physics degree and a certificate in strategic management.
  3. Mukesh Mehta: Non-Executive (Nominee) Director. He is a chartered accountant and chartered financial analyst with over 18 years of experience in private equity.
  4. Prateek Roongta: Non-Executive (Nominee) Director. He is a chartered accountant and company secretary with over 23 years of experience in portfolio management. He holds a commerce degree and a postgraduate diploma in management.
  5. Tejas Naphade: Non-Executive (Nominee) Director. He has a background in electrical engineering and business administration, with degrees from the Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, and Stanford University. He has around eight years of experience in private equity.
  6. Sangeeta Tanwani: Independent Director. She is the CEO of Pantaloons, a division of Aditya Birla Fashion & Retail Limited. She has a background in pharmaceuticals and business administration, with experience across several multinational companies.

Few example of report’s Given By International Gemmological Institute (India) IGI

Laboratory Grown Diamond Report

Colored Stone Report

Natural Diamond Report

Jewelry Report

Natural Diamond Report

34 Likes

On a lighter note,Makes me recall 2 opposing past events:the Bond movie DIAMONDS ARE FOREVER and the notorious still absconding Mehul Choksy of the scam tainted GITANJALI GEMS.
Btw,a smallcap lesser known MINI DIAMONDS is going great on bourses

4 Likes

For IGI in the last 3-4 years, the biggest growth has come from Lab Grown Diamond. Going forward also that is the biggest growth driver. Now the biggest risk to this is the falling prices of LGDs. In the Natural Diamonds, the way De Beers controls the prices, by restricting the supply, there is no single entity which can control prices of LGDs.
Now if excessive capacities for growing LGDs come up and due to which there is a massive fall in the prices, then that can spell doom for the industry. If the prices become too low, then the exclusivity factor in Diamond is gone and there may not be any need for certification as well.

Now for LGDs, how do the industry ensure that prices do not crash.
Going forward it in the steady state it may follow and undergo cycles of high demand and low demand, with cycles of under capacity and overcapacity. With prices rising during under capacity and rising during over capacity. This will happen when the demand globally is kind of stabilized and there is may be a steady single digit growth in demand.

But now when people are still discovering LGDs and their value, and market is growing thick and fast, and simultaneously capacities are also coming up to match the present and the future demand, the prices will remain very volatile. This phase of high growth may stay for another 3-5 years, before it kind of stabilizes. During this phase as Diamonds are coming from all kinds of sources and technologies, there will be great need for certification from independent credible body, so that one is able to assess the quality and value the diamond accordingly.
So feel that IGI should have good growth for the next 3-5 years at least.

The risk which we spoke earlier is if after this phase if the LGDs prices stabilizes at much lower levels and diamond loose their precious stone status then the need for certifications may vanish, which will detrimental for IGI.

Thanks.

15 Likes

Even price will reduce but certification will not vanish. Total export of LG of big company holds 95% of total sales which means they need certification without which export is not possible.

6 Likes

Expected a much better listing

2 Likes

Prices will stabilize due to minimum cost of production.

5 Likes

I have a few questions

  1. how does a company establish a competitive advantage inn this space ,as in do they use tech or is it just pure reputation based ?
  2. why would a company open training schools in an industry where a skill is a scarce resource , do they have some kind of agreement for non competence as in if you get trained in thier schools you ca only work with them .
  3. if LGD goes and becomes a commodity would the need for certification be still alive if yes why ?
  4. How does company indulge in business dev. i am assuming a big company like this just cant advertise alot
  5. threat to their market share
  6. the numbers look good an roe of around 82% is it sustainable ?
  7. the past growth was due to covid affect can we expect the same growth going forwards

disc - not invested but considering

8 Likes

The company has more than 50% revenue from Gujarat i.e. mostly Surat. But recent news suggests that the diamond industry in Surat is facing some of the worst times presently. Many diamond polishing units have shut down.

That means lower revenue expectations and depressed margins in near future.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.business-standard.com/amp/industry/news/surat-s-diamond-industry-hopes-to-regain-its-shine-this-festive-season-124102800720_1.html

Need to track the growth in such challenging environments.

2 Likes

It could be mainly due to LGD.

Because of India Diamonds market in surat only

IGI’s revenue comes not only from traditional diamonds but also increasingly from Lab-Grown Diamonds (LGDs). This segment has been a major growth driver over the past few years,

2 Likes

The International Gemological Institute IPO (Details updated as of 15th Dec)

Notes I took on the company while going through promoter interviews and IPO document

  1. The offer is a combination of OFS and fresh issue. ₹2750 Crs for sale and rest ₹1475 Crs as fresh issue out of which ₹1300 crs will be for acquiring the IGI Netherlands and Belgium subsidiary (more on it later)
  2. Post money valuation between ₹17k to ₹18k Cr. Blackstone bought the group for $550 Mn of enterprise value (4000 Crs) about a year and half back from Fosun. Now they are offloading it at a valuation of 16000 Cr.
  3. The sale of the subsidiaries (Neth & Belgium) are at an agreed equity value of ₹1300 Cr which can go upto max ₹1500 Crs
  4. Balance sheet size of 775 Crs where 83% of it is funded by equity.
  5. As of Sep 2024, the company had no debt and a cash balance of ~340 Crs.
  6. Given a pro-forma PAT of 435 Crs the company is trading at a PE of 38x and a price to sales (₹800 Cr) of 20x if the fresh issue does not go through and the IGI Netherlands and Belgium biz are not integrated (The IPO was was subscribed successfully)
  7. Pre acquisition, the Co boasts ~70% EBITDA margin and ~50% PAT margin growing at 30% y-o-y.
  8. Share of lab grown diamonds is 52%, followed by jewellery and coloured stones at 25%, followed by natural diamond certifications at 19% and education services at ~3%.
  9. Gemological Institute of America (GIA) is the biggest in the world, although they are not for profit.
  10. The margins for certification of lab grown diamonds and natural diamonds are different. This is because LGDs are made in labs in standardised batches whereas each natural diamonds is unique and has to go through a varied spectrum of checks.
  11. Also lab grown diamonds are volume based and thus the Co gives out a discount in their certification.
  12. Approximately average realisations would be under $20 and $50 for lab grown and natural diamonds respectively. The Co issues ~6 mn certs per year as per Mgt which flows to the end consumer.
  13. Someone questioned that as the share of lab grown diamonds increases margins should fall further then.
  14. In response to this management explained that they should be able to counter this by economies of scale and use of AI and other technologies.
  15. It was also asked that if the prices of lab grown diamonds fall further won’t it further affect margins. Mgt explained that it is less likely because LGDs are already had decent price shrinkage and if they go any further it would be unsustainable.
  16. Regarding the logic of the acquisition of the Netherland and Belgium entities, Mgt explained that although India was the primary hub for diamond cutting and polishing the main retail markets are outside India; in Europe and the US. The leadership in those regions are entrusted with the marketing and sales to the large retail chains which in turn drives the business in India.
  17. These centres also act to certify diamonds and studded jewellery in their given geographies as well.
  18. And because these are high cost branches they further reduce the margins. As such, post acquisition, PAT & EBITDA of the group will come down to ~30% and ~50% respectively. That being said the branches serve an important role as inputs to the Indian market.
  19. Another reason for acquiring the Netherland and Belgium biz is that the later holds the IGI brand/logo which would come to the India entity once the acquisition happens.
  20. Post OFS Blackstone would have a 76% share in the company which Mr. Printer thinks would continue for 10-12 years.
  21. The revenue model is based upon the number of certificates that IGI actually issues out for every stone that comes in the laboratory. The pricing is based upon the carat weight and has nothing to do with the quality of the diamond.
  22. About the supply of natural diamond mgt explains that there has been a slowdown in the segment primarily due to the Ukraine war. Russia supplies 30-35% of the natural rough on which there is an embargo.
  23. Upon asking why the post acquisition PAT was lower than India PAT, mgt explained that there were some senior management changes due to which severance pays had to be doled out which reduced the post acquisition PAT. Essentially there was a loss in the Netherlands and Belgium units combined.

Valuations looked stretched. Not Invested at current levels!!

12 Likes

If pricing is also not based per carat price of lgd then, even if prices of lgd fall, it should not have an impact on the margins assuming volume growth remains as it is. Also assuming
that if prices fall, industry will consolidate to organised/formal players with more OL and thus volumes of lgd certifications can grow healthily in medium term.

1 Like

If the overall prices of LGDs fall further, the margins of IGI would be impacted. This is because the producers of these LGDs will try to protect their margins in turn forcing savings in the downstream processes such as cutting, polishing and grading/certification. An overall fall in the prices would not be good as the thinning margins would be unsustainable in the long term for every player in the value segment except the final consumers. I am certain that the LGD producers would collude to protect prices dropping below a certain range.

1 Like

The current LGD prices have already hit rock bottom, making further reductions is
unsustainable. This could force LGD producers to shut operations, leading to consolidation in the industry. I am optimistic about a rebound in LGD prices in the coming years.

Agreed on push on margin reduction but i think that is limited because -

  1. Certification may become mandatory by law, Press Release:Press Information Bureau
  2. Since jewellery is fraud prone item, more customer awareness means they would always want a certified diamond more so with lab prepared thing similar to hallmark thing. So certification becomes non-negotiable as it is something which ensures veracity of diamond.
  3. Also certification is a duopoly would be interesting to see how much GIA and IGI are bendable to a highly split and fragmented LGD manufacturing industry unlike natural.

In any case these are worst to worst outcomes that can happen, agreed on very low chances of drastic fall in LGD prices.

Disc - Invested

4 Likes

is this assessment based on any objective reasoning or just wishful thinking?

1 Like

As per this article, IGI is consistently cheaper than GIA, so if LGD prices comes down, IGI might grab market share from GIA.

https://www.diamondscreener.com/education/comparing-diamond-certification-labs-gia-vs-igi-grading-and-prices/

1 Like

Does anyone know why their other two subsidiaries are loss making?

Evrything seems good a bit too good.