Hitesh portfolio

@mzambare

I dont specifically track Azad engineering. But a cursory look at screener provides some idea about the valuations of the company. I usually don’t give too much importance to conventional valuation parameters, but if the valuations are totally out of whack, I dont even bother to look at the company.

Market cap is 18000 crores.

TTM turnover is 638 crores.

TTM profits are 140 crores.

Calculate the market cap to sales ratio, and current PE for the stock. I rest my case.:grinning_face:

16 Likes

NARRATIVE VERSUS NUMBERS.

There is a very common thread to a lot of multibaggers these days, and has been over the past too.. But its much more pronounced these days because of the ease of spread of information.

First is the multibaggers that arise out of Narrative. This usually happens when there is lot of talk about a particular sector or market segment being too exciting for the future. Here the talk centres about the kind of growth this sector is going to experience often projected into infinity. And then stocks that “BENEFIT” out of this sectoral potential are touted as the next bunch of multibaggers. This narrative gradually gathers momentum, and stock price starts rising and keeps going up and up.. Earnings growth are still a few quarters away, but by the time the earnings start (they often do not manifest only, but that’s a different scenario) most of the juice is out of the stock. Even if growth continues, stock price does not appreciate meaningfully.

However if the company delivers on the growth promise, valuations can sustain and often expand. But this is a scenario that is not too often seen. Maybe one or two out of ten companies can get into this category. In rest of the companies, the rally tends to fizzle out and stock price tends to correct, or go sideways for prolonged periods.

The other category of multibagger stocks is the one where numbers dominate the story. There is very strong growth in numbers, and often they keep showing up better than expected. Here there is a good scope of a head cocktail of growth plus PE rerating and that leads to big and durable multibaggers. Once growth doesnt keep pace with valuations, these stocks also correct.

While evaluating any investing opportunity these days, its important to slot what kind of investing landscape the particular company fits into. And one has to play it accordingly.

71 Likes

@hitesh2710

Sir, I’ve read Mark Minervini’s book and William O’Neil’s and other books around the same some once some twice and some concepts multiple times. I understand the basic concepts and frameworks, but I still feel that something is incomplete in my understanding.

I think what I’m missing is conviction—not just the conviction to select a stock, but more importantly, the conviction to reject a stock even when it appears to satisfy all the criteria.

Initially, I filtered companies using O’Neil’s fundamental criteria and Mark’s Code 33. I got some very good names, including Rubicon and UTL Solar. I took positions in some of them and made money, but I noticed that the really significant moves often came only around results.

Then I started looking for companies that were fundamentally good, already in an uptrend, and forming VCPs with tightening price action and all the other characteristics that Minervini talks about. But several stocks I selected—Quality Power, Netweb, Azad Engineering, Aeroflex and SEDEMAC, for example—didn’t behave as I expected. They either broke out and moved only 5–6% before stalling, while at the same time other stocks were moving 10–20% day after day.

I even asked the AI on a stock-screening platform (paid version) about this, and it pointed out that some of these stocks had already made a 200%+ move, so perhaps it was unrealistic to expect them to deliver the same explosive move as stocks that had not yet had such a large run.

But this is where I’m getting confused. Minervini and O’Neil repeatedly emphasize that the stock should already be strong—that the moving averages should be trending upward, the RS line should be improving, and that prior price appreciation is actually a positive. In fact, a stock that has already moved 50%, 100%, or even more is often considered preferable to a stock that has done nothing.

So where exactly is the distinction? How do I differentiate between a stock that has already had a major move and is now capable of another explosive leg versus one that has simply become too mature or extended?

Because of this confusion, I temporarily changed my approach. I started scanning at the end of the day for stocks that had just broken out on strong volume and then made a list of stocks that might move the next day.

Surprisingly, this did identify some very strong moves. Some stocks hit upper circuits around 20%, while others moved 10% or more. But the problem is that I have no idea beforehand which one will be the 20% stock and which one will barely move. And if I simply take a bet on all of them with a very tight stop-loss, I don’t feel that is a viable strategy either.

There is another problem. The list keeps growing every day. I can easily find 10–15 stocks that have broken out or are showing some kind of strength, and after a point it becomes overwhelming to track all of them—whether they will continue, pull back, form a proper entry, fail, or turn into a larger trend.

And psychologically, I’m also struggling with something else.

For example, Wheels India was a stock I had already filtered in the past. I had studied the company, spent considerable time understanding the setup, and ultimately didn’t buy it for whatever reason. Then it gave a 20% upper circuit and another ~15% move the next day.

That bothers me because, in one sense, it tells me that I was doing something right. I had actually found the stock before the move. What I failed to do was identify the right moment and have enough conviction to act.

So I feel I’m stuck between two extremes:

1. If I filter stocks beforehand based on Minervini/O’Neil criteria, I get many good stocks, but I don’t know which ones will actually produce the explosive move.

2. If I wait for the explosive volume breakout and then try to participate, I get too many candidates, and I don’t know which ones will continue and which ones will fail.

And somewhere in between, I’m probably missing the actual skill that these traders are trying to teach—which may not simply be “finding good stocks,” but knowing which good stocks to ignore, which ones to prioritize, and when the probability is sufficiently high to actually take a position.

It has also become quite overwhelming over the past week. I’m spending a lot of time studying charts and companies, and because I currently have a few relatively lighter months in residency, I’ve temporarily shifted a significant amount of my focus toward learning this skill properly.

So I wanted to ask you: from this point, how should I proceed?

Is the solution actually to stop trying to predict which stock will be “the next big mover” and instead build a systematic process around a small number of high-quality setups and simply sit tight and wait for the right ones to emerge?

One more thing I find particularly difficult is the concept of buying at the pivot. We are told to identify the pivot and buy as the stock breaks out, but in real time the pivot often seems obvious only after the breakout has already happened. By then, the stock may already be 3–5% above the pivot and considered extended. So how do we identify and mark the potential pivot beforehand with enough confidence to prepare an entry, while still avoiding false breakouts? How does an experienced trader distinguish between a valid pivot that can be anticipated and a level that only becomes obvious in hindsight?

Am I still missing an important part of the O’Neil/Minervini framework—particularly the part about conviction to reject, prioritization, and distinguishing a genuinely high-potential setup from a stock that merely checks all the boxes?

Previously I used to select companies based on fundamentals more but i also read Stan Weinsten book and he said the stock can move before the results are actually visible as well this is true i have seen some stocks giving great move just 2-3 days before results and then not moving at all after results are announced it actually feels that someone knew about it.

I would really appreciate your guidance on how you think I should structure my learning and process from here, some other books, some others sources, what was your experience, how you managed this how you tackled this? As I am a 2nd year PG Sir putting more time and effort to gaining and improving this skill as currently having light duties, but later I’ll have to focus on exams and my residency as well.

14 Likes

Apologies @hitesh2710 sir I could not stop myself responding to it.

Hi Mohit @mzambare just read your message, I fell in love with your extremely elaborated message and I felt these are my words but for different problems. What you are asking for is - Perfection.

Your message made me realise I also seek perfection. I keep making mistakes everyday. I kick myself for selling early, buying expensive, act on fomo, act without due diligence, act in panic.

However, over the past 15 years, when I look back I feel ok. I evolved, I learnt. When I look at the results, i feel ok with outcome - 30%+ cagr.

I note that you started with Warren Buffet, buy what you understand to now - Mark Minervani and O Neil. So you are not static.

You will continue to evolve. Hope in the long-term you can say you did fine despite kicking yourself everyday. You are young its just begining, give time but continue to ask questions.

Just one input from my side is Hitesh sir is also looking at fundamentals - valuations, business, growth along with technicals.

25 Likes

Hi Hitesh Bhai. Hope you are doing good.

What are your views on SJS Enterprises? Whenever I think of this company, it comes to my mind as the kind of “boring company” which Peter Lynch describes in One Up on Wall Street. They manufacture stickers, badges and aesthetic components for automobile companies. The products are relatively inexpensive compared to the value of the motorbikes or cars, but carry great value when it comes to the overall look of the vehicle. I also find their business to have customer stickiness as i dont think auto companies would want to change them merely for small cost savings.

For its size, it is debt-free as well. The management in the recent call says its growth has consistently outperformed the underlying automotive industry for 27 consecutive quarters. The stock is not cheap, but compared to others, it is relatively not expensive either.

Also, would like to know how you see the cables and wires stocks falling like a pack of cards just because ultratech has entered the business. Do you think the market is overreacting to the competitive threat, or can this entry structurally affect the growth, margins and valuations of the existing players such as KEI and Polycab?

Based on your experience of following companies and markets, have you seen similar situations in the past where the entry of a large player ended up changing the economics of an otherwise strong industry? Anything in particular one should watch out for here? One example most cited is Birla opus which ate significant market share of Asian Paints. Do you think the same is going to happen here as well.

7 Likes

Been holding SJS for more than 1.5 yrs now. The main thesis kicking into play slowly seems to be the kit value increasing 5-7x for passenger vehicles and double for 2W segment. It is a picks and shovels play for the auto industry - doesn’t matter which OEM comes out with a hit model, these guys will make money either way by selling to most OEMs. They’re also adamant on ramping up exports to 14-15% of total revenue, currently its ~10%. Upcoming Q2 results should be great too because of the record auto sales we’ve been seeing last month.

Disc: invested and holding

9 Likes

@mzambare

Its good to see the zeal and efforts you put in to hasten the learning process. My advice would be to keep the process going, try improving on these processes and sharpen the processes.

At times, markets are not conducive to big returns. We have had such markets ever since September 2024. Its been almost 24 months now and by and large stocks have remained flattish.

There is a very narrow bunch of stocks that have shown exponential moves during these tough times. Stocks like those with very strong narratives of growth like the AI and data centre stocks. Others where numbers have been largely supportive for a couple of quarters or more have moved. I found a lot of auto and more particularly auto ancillary stocks in the group.

A lot of set ups on charts that satisfy all the criteria for bullish moves are failing or stalling. That is more to do with the overall markets than any other factor. Besides when too many people start following a particular method it often tends to lose its edge. These days wherever you see on social media or elsewhere, the most common words that hit you are Minervini, VCP, Breakouts, Retests so on and so forth. So maybe its time to change tracks and try to find bottoming patterns.

If you can find bottoming patterns in stocks with turnaround results, or consistent growth, there will be good low risk entry points, and chances of higher returns. However these set ups tend to test your patience because big moves often take a long long time and many a times, it is frustrating to see these stocks languish and see other stocks fly. But that’s the price you pay for playing safe.

In the early stage of your investing career, try to enjoy the process of learning rather than focus too much on returns. Once you have read and digested important learnings, there is a whole lifetime to apply these during favorable markets and make returns.

Stock market returns are never linear. There will be phases of no returns or negligible or less than expected returns, and then there will be periods of explosive returns. Idea should be to be on the lookout for the latter phase of markets and hit the fat pitches.

My investing experience and returns have been dominated by few big winners. I have been latching on to one or two big winners every couple of years, and those have provided good returns. My forte as I have realised is allocation. I have been able to allocate big to some multibaggers right from early stage of finding them. And for me that’s what has made the big difference.

But this approach too is not free from headwinds. At times, your top allocated stock does not move much inspite of a lot of stuff ticking the boxes. During these times, it makes sense to set aside your ego and reduce the allocation and move on to something else.

No matter how learned, or experienced you are, you will face frustration in the markets from time to time. And during those times (as the current time), it helps to keep a cool head and patience. Markets are like busy railway stations or airports. One flight takes off, and if you miss it, there is always a next one coming soon. We have to be ready with our stuff to board it when the time feels right.

THIS TOO SHALL PASS… is a very useful sentence for investors. Keeps you grounded during bullish times, and hopeful during bad times.

100 Likes

Hello @hitesh2710 Sir, I am back with another silly query.:sweat_smile:

Last month with the help of all the learning, I made some 50k in profits. But this month after all the deppwr technical learning, I’ve been stopped out of few of my old positions and also the trades I took in past few days. Seeing my portfolio loose 3-4% (appx 40k in absolute value) it feels devastating. Anyway I am trying to convince myself THIS TO SHALL PASS. it’s good that my stop loss hit and I cut my losses but sir still psychologically it’s a drag. JUST SEEING THAT 3-4K OF Realized loss on P&L for this month feels bad, like I am doing something wrong, or what if i fail or end up below average in this as well as my primary career? So sir please suggest some books/sources related to how to handle this psychological Aspect of trading/investing. (Need to hit breaks on learning new chart/technical aspects and keep getting in trades now). Asking you because you’ll give best in class sources, google and amazon just sponser promoted book. Had ordered few and returned because didn’t like the content. :sweat_smile:

Also sir if you could share your personal experience have you ever experienced these bad days? Or months? Of losses? Or bad trades? And how you Handled it? Any psychological models/ routines that helped you?

4 Likes

@mzambare

As mentioned in earlier post, during early part of investing career, which is more of learning phase, its better to focus on learnings than returns. Once learnings come and are digested, returns inevitably follow.

If its any comfort to you, my portfolio also took a dive of around 3-4% within last 2 days. Usually that’s par for the course. There will be the bad days.

Best thing to do is to evaulate portfolio on a slightly longer time frame.. Maybe every month or every quarter. Then this kind of pain and heartburn will be bearable.

During a bear phase (as we currently seem to be in these days), portfolios taking a hit of 20-30 (usually) , or sometimes even 40% is quite normal.

I had a dream run in terms of portfolio returns from 2009-2018 during which time it compounded at a very high rate. This was on the back of some big winners like Ajanta, PI, Manjushree technopak, Mayur uniquoters, Kaveri seeds, Canfin etc. And post 2018 my portfolio languished for a lot of time and by the time the Covid correction started, it was down 40% from peak levels seen in 2018. That induced me to sell everything and sit back and re assess my strategy. In hindsight I realised that 2018-2020 was the bull market for QUALITY (at any price) stocks and small and midcaps underperformed for nearly 2 years.

Post Covid again the golden period version 2 started, and this time with strategy of high allocation, and being lucky in terms of the highest allocation stock going up a lot, PF returns again did very well. So 2020-Sep 2024 was a great period, and since then PF valuation levels have largely been stuck in a range. In fact at some point in 2025, it was down nearly 40-45% from peak levels in line with correction in HBL stock price. Since then I reduced concentration to it and did some short term and medium term trading in some positions, and gradually inched upwards.

But having seen the upcycle followed by flat cycle in PF returns over a long period of time, there is an inherent confidence that when markets are more conducive and once I get a couple of more fat pitches right, I will again be on my way. Till that time I keep looking at companies where I see potential for good returns.

The way the current market correction lasting nearly 2 years (interspersed with some rallies) has played out, there will be some sitting ducks in the multibagger category. Our job is to try to find them, do proper research and load up if the risk reward is favorable.

There are very few resources on psychological aspect of investing or trading. But over a period of time market is often the best teacher provided we are ready to observe and learn. And there will always be others who will keep landing more winners as compared to you, but for us what matters is our own returns and how to improve them, and how to minimise damage during downdrafts.

For me, One Up on Wall street (read multiple times), is the holy grail of all learnings. If you can read in between the lines even the psychological aspect of investing and even bubbles, market fancies, fallen angels etc are all covered there. Cannot find anything better than that book.

68 Likes

Yes sir you sharing your experience and PF was of great help. :folded_hands:

Thank you so much for your response. Will do better.

1 Like

@mzambare: Reading your posts and admire the curiosity you are showing at such a young age. You are on the right path.

You have gained knowledge by reading from various sources. It’s time to develop conviction about various businesses you like. Finally, have patience and wait for the opportunity when valuations are attractive. Market provides opportunities to prepared mind, but not everyday and at the frequency we wish for.

As of now, your approach to make money is mere speculation and not investing. Most market participants can’t manufacture returns on a regular basis, at least not in the starting phase.

You are learning fast and trying to earn faster. I suggest you slow down on your aspiration to earn faster and swing hard when find a fat pitch.

19 Likes

Dear @hitesh2710 ji,

I have seen your earliest posts where you have explained how some sectors become very attractive due to lots of positive sentiment and how the stock prices run way ahead of fundamentals for some time and then drop back.

Do you see similar pattern occuring in the Aerospace (and perhaps new age A&D) sector & companies off late?

2 Likes

Hi @hitesh2710 sir,

Thank you so much for all the guidance you have given over the years.

You had posted about Jana Small Finance Bank earlier, particularly around the entry of the TVS Group. But now there is news that Federal Bank is planning to take over Jana. How do you see this development?

Does this change your thesis on Jana?

1 Like

Hi @hitesh2710 Sir,
If possible can you please share your strategy for NBFC investments, considering the expected rate hike cycle?"

How did you find hbl could you tell us the process how you found this gem. What was the initial thing that attracted you to it. Just want to know the process how you are able to consistently find these gems.

1 Like

@Anant started a thread on Collaborator’s corner on HBL titled HBL signs of change in May 2022. Price had just broken out above previous all time highs of 77 posted back in 2017. The write up contained all the investment arguments and expected developments in the company.

Post that price oscillated between 75-110 range till March 2023. That’s nearly 9 months to study the company in details and accumulate your desired quantity of shares of the company.

I remember having posted a chart on the company soon after the thread started. What initially began as a techno funda bet ultimately became a multibagger of big proportions.

Since I was convinced about the story and the techno funda picture fitted picture perfect, I allocated a decent size of my capital to it and it became one of the most rewarding investments for me.

Note that around that time, and in subsequent time frame, there were a lot of rumours/newsflows floating around related to promoter having issues with govt authorities.

Markets often provide you many such opportunities during prolonged bear markets similar to the current one we are in. Its upon us to find out the best options and allocate decent capital to them.

The usual picture is of fundamental changes in a company be it a new product, new geography, or decent growth in existing business, debt reduction/restructuring/ promoter acquisition/ capex/ favorable govt policies or other tailwinds which builds a strong narrative around the stock and breakout with volumes above previous all time highs, or multiyear highs, sometimes sprinkled with some negative irrelevant newsflow related to the company, or promoters, which keeps the stock price oscillating around the breakout levels for few weeks to few months.

And then some trigger appears (in HBL it was an unfortunate event of a train accident in Orissa, other times it can be explosion in earnings, or other such factors ) which takes the stock prices to a new orbit. And then there is no looking back.

These kind of situations keep repeating consistently in markets, more often during bear markets, where triggers are clearly visible, the writing for a winner is on the wall, but weak markets often holds back the stock price rally, or its some company specific negative newsflow, and that’s the opportunity to pounce after doing enough due diligence.

47 Likes

One of my recent (last six months) investments has been in Jayaswals Neco. We have a very detailed write up put up by @aashav23 with all the relevant investment triggers, and business details back in March 2026.

Here, previous all time high was 84 back in January 2008. It was crossed in October 2025, and stock price went up to hit a fresh all time high of 117 in May 2026. All these things happened on the back of decent results for q4 Fy 26. Debt reduction which was an important investment argument is well on track. q1 Fy 27 results also have been good.

Here a promoter group company was implicated (rightly or wrongly its difficult to make out, but company had come up with an explanation about its stance through a document shared on the bourses) in some defence deal scandal in supply to Estonian govt. This caused the stock price to correct sharply and since then the breakout level of 84 has been retested and stock price has been consolidating around 85-104 during recent weeks.

My reading on the company is as follows

POSITIVES:

Fundamentals playing out as per initial investment thesis. (some parameters appear better than expected)

Debt reduction addressed aggressively.

Preferential allotment of convertible warrants to promoter group at 89 rs per share worth 200 crores. (currently stock price is hovering at and around these levels give or take a few rupees)

Excellent techno funda picture. (cannot share charts due to restrictions but anyone can pull up a chart and do their own analysis)

Strong steel cycle going on . (this can change quickly so one needs to monitor continuously)

NEGATIVES:

Its in a cyclical industry and hence entails the associated risks.

Negative newsflow related to promoter owned entity (not directly affecting Jay Neco business) embroiled in issues with Estonian govt supply tender.

Overall weak market.

HOW TO DO RESEARCH ON THIS COMPANY.

Read the detailed thread started by Aashav. Cross check facts with documents like AR, presentations, other documents, maybe even use AI, if you are good at it.

Check if whatever positive triggers enlisted in the intial write up are playing out or not, by checking results, balance sheet, AR, announcement etc.

Check strength in price action, by observing how it performs with respect to overall markets. Say compare its chart to that of Nifty 500, or even Nifty 50. Whether there is outperformance, or not. Check whether its holding above key moving averages like 200 dema, 30 WEMA, or any other method you are comfortable with if you practice some form of price action analysis or technical analysis.

disc: I own this stock, and have been buying on declines during recent mayhem. This is not an investment advice as I am not a SEBI registered advisor. If you contemplate investment in this company do your own diligence and then take an informed decision, or take advice of your investment advisor.

59 Likes

Hi @hitesh2710 sir, I would appreciate your perspective on a situation I often encounter as an investor.

e.g. Muthoot Microfin has corrected significantly and underperformed the broader market despite reporting good financial results and providing positive management commentary. The company’s fundamentals appear intact, with no obvious negative developments apart from the potential impact of an upcoming drought on the microfinance sector.

In such cases where original thesis in intract but a stock continues to fall despite seemingly strong fundamentals and positive developments, how do we determine whether the market is anticipating something we haven’t identified or whether the stock is simply waiting for the market to recognise its underlying value?

As an investor, what indicators or analytical frameworks do you use to distinguish between these two possibilities and avoid falling into a value trap?

4 Likes

your answer lies here. portfolio heavily dependent on south and west especially Maharashtra. Drought is declared in Maharashtra and Karnataka. Same is applicable to suryoday bank also. There is uncertainties in future and that’s why market is in wait and watch mode.

7 Likes

hI @hitesh2710 ji,

Thanks for wisdom from you time to time. Another earning season has come to an end. In Q2 many of the stocks gave good sales/profit/EPS growth and this is true for small cap space as well. However, I see that small cap recovery or response to good results is slow compared to large cap. How do you read Q2 results and sectors which likely to perform well ? There is fear of rural stress due to El Nino. But, geopolitical situation looking to easing out US mid term poll loss of Trump. Also FII is back this month.

In light of all these changes, your keen observations will be helpful in sectors/different market caps on what do you think looks good and overall direction of market.

3 Likes