@hitesh2710
Sir, I’ve read Mark Minervini’s book and William O’Neil’s and other books around the same some once some twice and some concepts multiple times. I understand the basic concepts and frameworks, but I still feel that something is incomplete in my understanding.
I think what I’m missing is conviction—not just the conviction to select a stock, but more importantly, the conviction to reject a stock even when it appears to satisfy all the criteria.
Initially, I filtered companies using O’Neil’s fundamental criteria and Mark’s Code 33. I got some very good names, including Rubicon and UTL Solar. I took positions in some of them and made money, but I noticed that the really significant moves often came only around results.
Then I started looking for companies that were fundamentally good, already in an uptrend, and forming VCPs with tightening price action and all the other characteristics that Minervini talks about. But several stocks I selected—Quality Power, Netweb, Azad Engineering, Aeroflex and SEDEMAC, for example—didn’t behave as I expected. They either broke out and moved only 5–6% before stalling, while at the same time other stocks were moving 10–20% day after day.
I even asked the AI on a stock-screening platform (paid version) about this, and it pointed out that some of these stocks had already made a 200%+ move, so perhaps it was unrealistic to expect them to deliver the same explosive move as stocks that had not yet had such a large run.
But this is where I’m getting confused. Minervini and O’Neil repeatedly emphasize that the stock should already be strong—that the moving averages should be trending upward, the RS line should be improving, and that prior price appreciation is actually a positive. In fact, a stock that has already moved 50%, 100%, or even more is often considered preferable to a stock that has done nothing.
So where exactly is the distinction? How do I differentiate between a stock that has already had a major move and is now capable of another explosive leg versus one that has simply become too mature or extended?
Because of this confusion, I temporarily changed my approach. I started scanning at the end of the day for stocks that had just broken out on strong volume and then made a list of stocks that might move the next day.
Surprisingly, this did identify some very strong moves. Some stocks hit upper circuits around 20%, while others moved 10% or more. But the problem is that I have no idea beforehand which one will be the 20% stock and which one will barely move. And if I simply take a bet on all of them with a very tight stop-loss, I don’t feel that is a viable strategy either.
There is another problem. The list keeps growing every day. I can easily find 10–15 stocks that have broken out or are showing some kind of strength, and after a point it becomes overwhelming to track all of them—whether they will continue, pull back, form a proper entry, fail, or turn into a larger trend.
And psychologically, I’m also struggling with something else.
For example, Wheels India was a stock I had already filtered in the past. I had studied the company, spent considerable time understanding the setup, and ultimately didn’t buy it for whatever reason. Then it gave a 20% upper circuit and another ~15% move the next day.
That bothers me because, in one sense, it tells me that I was doing something right. I had actually found the stock before the move. What I failed to do was identify the right moment and have enough conviction to act.
So I feel I’m stuck between two extremes:
1. If I filter stocks beforehand based on Minervini/O’Neil criteria, I get many good stocks, but I don’t know which ones will actually produce the explosive move.
2. If I wait for the explosive volume breakout and then try to participate, I get too many candidates, and I don’t know which ones will continue and which ones will fail.
And somewhere in between, I’m probably missing the actual skill that these traders are trying to teach—which may not simply be “finding good stocks,” but knowing which good stocks to ignore, which ones to prioritize, and when the probability is sufficiently high to actually take a position.
It has also become quite overwhelming over the past week. I’m spending a lot of time studying charts and companies, and because I currently have a few relatively lighter months in residency, I’ve temporarily shifted a significant amount of my focus toward learning this skill properly.
So I wanted to ask you: from this point, how should I proceed?
Is the solution actually to stop trying to predict which stock will be “the next big mover” and instead build a systematic process around a small number of high-quality setups and simply sit tight and wait for the right ones to emerge?
One more thing I find particularly difficult is the concept of buying at the pivot. We are told to identify the pivot and buy as the stock breaks out, but in real time the pivot often seems obvious only after the breakout has already happened. By then, the stock may already be 3–5% above the pivot and considered extended. So how do we identify and mark the potential pivot beforehand with enough confidence to prepare an entry, while still avoiding false breakouts? How does an experienced trader distinguish between a valid pivot that can be anticipated and a level that only becomes obvious in hindsight?
Am I still missing an important part of the O’Neil/Minervini framework—particularly the part about conviction to reject, prioritization, and distinguishing a genuinely high-potential setup from a stock that merely checks all the boxes?
Previously I used to select companies based on fundamentals more but i also read Stan Weinsten book and he said the stock can move before the results are actually visible as well this is true i have seen some stocks giving great move just 2-3 days before results and then not moving at all after results are announced it actually feels that someone knew about it.
I would really appreciate your guidance on how you think I should structure my learning and process from here, some other books, some others sources, what was your experience, how you managed this how you tackled this? As I am a 2nd year PG Sir putting more time and effort to gaining and improving this skill as currently having light duties, but later I’ll have to focus on exams and my residency as well.