Thank you for the update!! To summarise, disgusting Corp Governance practices!! Nothing been done over the last few years ( expansion into fish feed was being said since many years and haven’t seen any major development). On the contrary, company/ industry has been hit by major negative developments. And some negative developments even due to company’s oversight!! All in all, no improvement in earnings over the last few yrs… and amidst all this, they r announcing salary hike for management & independent directors!! And that too to meet their living needs!!! If 20 Cr annual salaried person is unable to meet his/ her needs, God save many of us!!! One of the classic example of how minority shareholders r kicked away and management keeps becoming richer & richer…I feel, with these hikes, any motivation left in the management would further be killed to improve status quo affairs. Hope such idiotic things r not passed through
Sales is not issue here, Margins are. Due to steep hike in Raw material prices ,EBITDA margins are not sustained.
Superb execution by Avanti. Contrasting results vs the competitor.
Shows market leadership.
Disc: Invested in family acs
Return of margins?
“Domestic soymeal prices have continued to correct in the month of May itself. Prices corrected over the last one month following a decline in edible oil prices. Price is currently at Rs 49/kg down from highs Rs 95/kg seen in Q2FY22.”
Soymeal price falling since March, auguring well for shrimp companies Soymeal price falling since March, auguring well for shrimp companies
As per concall, Soyameal in May was at 69rs and the management mentioned that they had high inventory of RM. FY22 vs FY21- Fishmeal inventory of 242cr vs 118cr, Soyameal 197cr (28568 MT) vs 53cr (10,274 MT). …
“So, what you’re seeing in the balance sheet is on the date of 31st March, which happens to be the financial year ending day which coincides with the commencement of our season, subsequently April, May, June, okay. So that’s the reason why we keep enough stocks for production in April, May, June, but this year, we have kept more than what is required. See normally what we do is when the Soyabean was freely available in the market, we were storing around 15 to 20 days only. But now because there is a shortage of Soyabean we are we increased the stocking levels to one month now”
"The present prices are higher than what inventory cost that we have as on 31st March. So, we are at the advantageous position. If we were to buy today, it would have costed much more to us. "
I think the drop in soyameal spot price may not reflect immediately in the numbers. There will be a lag for RM price correction to reflect in numbers. My guess is that margins in feed should start to improve from Q2.
There was also this comment “we are booked with the government permitted input we have booked the 14,000 tons which we are expecting would cost us around rs54, but we normally use most of our products with high protein which will be higher by 5,000 per metric ton. The normal plus rs 5000 is our cost, high protein”
You are right that as the co is carrying very high inventory vs their normal levels, I think it may take time before the margin expansion happens (though they did good margins in Q4 and perhaps the same should continue).
I feel that given the leadership of the company and contrastingly better executions vs peers, the market would be forward-looking to such positive industry changes.
Lets see how things unfold.
Disc: Invested in family and client acs
Venkys declared their Q1 result and their margin got affected due to High price of soya and corn
Soya price rise could also affect earnings of Avanti Feed ?
in the recent con call management clarified that
- supply from ecuador is not of any concern , in short term as well as long term)
- not carrying much inventory
- hoping for Aug-Oct q better than last year
- optimistic for price rise in aug-sep , based on discussion with regulators and farmers.
Muted set of nos from the feed division of Avanti. Margin revival is still a couple of quarters away. Concall notes below
- Estimate shrimp feed consumption of 12.5-13 lakh MT in CY22 with production of 8-8.5 lakh MT shrimp
- Could not meet the demand due to capex delay which impacted shrimp feed volumes. Projecting sales of 5.7-5.8 lakh MT feeds in calendar year 2022
- Almost completed shrimp feed expansion of 1.75 lakh MTPA with estimated capex of 125 cr. (vs 50 cr. mentioned earlier). Commercial production should start in September 2022
- Should be able to meet the excess demand in next growing season with capacity coming on stream
- Out of 1.75 lakh MTPA of new capacity coming in, only about 80% is realizable as it’s a seasonal business
- Seeing soft shrimp demand in US, expect it to revive in November
- As FDA has terminated recall in May 2022, company has applied for removal of import alert
Disclosure: Invested (position size here, no transactions in last-30 days)
What is their logic behind dismissing Ecuador as a concern?
I went through the annual report and have the below query on their declining operating profit.
26,427.74 in FY21-22 against 40,419.30 in FY20-21
This is despite an increase in the revenue. Can we attribute to the lower profit only to increase in raw-material cost (feed, packaging, logistics) which they are not able to completely transfer it to the farmers who are their main customers?
Also I could see a huge negative inventory affecting its operating cash flow. This is contradictory to their statement that despite COVID challenges, the sales has increased. If so, why this unsold inventory?
(40,133.52) in FY21-22 against 5,702.52 in FY20-21
Disc: have a small tracking position and planning to add more once the price bottoms out and start an upward trend
The increase in inventory in FY21-22 was due to the firm acquiring a lot of the RMs uupfront, anticipating the significant inflation thorugh most of CY22.
Also, most of the margin pressure is attributable to the RM headwinds, which should subside from here (already improving sequentially basis management commentary).
Flattish sales from Avanti with revival in margins. Q4FY23 looks ominous, with 25% decline in shrimp seed sales in the first 45 days of the quarter. Concall notes below.
- Expect CY23 shrimp production at 8.5 lakh MT (vs 9 lakh MT in CY22)
- Present RM price: 110/kg fish meal (export prices are 150/kg causing hike in domestic pries), 57/kg soyabean, 36/kg wheat (expect price softening)
- Annual fishmeal production is 3.75 – 4 lakh MT and Shrimp Feed Industry consumes 3 lakhs MT
- Until mid-February’23, shrimp seed stocking was 5700 Mn vs 7800 Mn Seed during last year
- Lost 50,000 MT of feed sales due to delay in commissioning of new plant
- Feed Capex: Completed expansion of 175’000 MT in December 2022 which will contribute 25% more sales at full utilization
- Shrimp processing capex
- Focusing on value-added products shrimps, where margins are higher. Started 2-3 categories of value-added products (current share of value added products is 25% of sales)
- In value added shrimps, can only operate at 60-65% utilization as it requires more manual work
- Peak season working capital requirement is 800-900 cr. Despite that, they still have 1000 cr.+ cash
Disclosure: Invested (position size here, no transactions in last-30 days)
Avanti Feeds might be at or reaching cyclical bottom. There could be a bit more pain and re-rating could be slow due to macro conditions. But, from a 2 year horizon, this seems to be a good time to accumulate.
Some of my rationale for identifying this as cyclical bottom:
- Input costs for Avanti has increased due to increase in prices of fishmeal, Soybean, Wheat and Cereals. This is also affecting the poultry sector (you can check margins of Venky’s India as well). As a result, EBIDT & OPM margins are at 10 year lows for Avanti.
- US FDA restriction on cooked shrimp is also lifted. But, it hasn’t resulted in export growth yet. Also, China is just opening up and consumption is expected to revive.
- Freight costs might be coming down, adding some cost savings.
- COVID has been a terrible period for the shrimp industry with demand faltering and production constrained. This has forced many farmers out of business and many going for a crop holiday till April 2023.
- Industry is still grappling with negative sentiments from farmers (demand side). The problems got worse to the extent that government needed to step in to mediate pricing on feed as well as offtake.
- This resulted in Avanti not being able to increase feed price and at the same time forced to absorb high raw material cost.
- There is severe lack of automation and technology use in shrimp farming. 60% of farmers are small and marginal.
- Indian domestic consumption has not been tapped well. Given that Indian diet largely misses animal protein (with poultry as the primary source), there is a good scope for shrimps to fill in the gap
- Meanwhile, Ecuador is proving to be a tough competitor recently, capturing India’s export market share. To me, this is a significant reason for the downcycle to be a bit more prolonged.
- Lastly, the frequency of posts in this thread is also at bottom , indicating negative investor sentiment.
Positives going ahead
- On a long term aspect, India has huge land availability for shrimp farming. Coupled with increased domestic consumption, I am optimistic on sustainable growth rate of above 10% (might take a while to dig out of current cycle)
- Govt has reduced duties on fish feed and is trying to support the industry through policies
- CAPEX and commissioning of new plant will yield good topline growth and better ROCE
- Potential to look into fish feed market which would be another leg of growth
- Potential for margin expansion from value added products
- Stock price is reaching attractive levels now (PE<20) compared to the potential earnings going ahead
- Company has enough cash to survive and exploit the cyclical nature of industry. They are also rightfully holding the cash for working capital purpose than just to reduce cash in balance sheet
Not sure if Avanti is applying waste management processes. For example, shrimp heads can be reused in feed, shrimp shells can be used to extract chemicals for pharma and paper industry.
A good overview on Indian Shrimp industry and recommendations to govt and industry
Disc: Started nibbling with SIP