A must read letter for followers of TV Channel Experts (Momentum Experts)

A letter from a bruised bull to the "expert"analyst.

My dear Analyst,

I have been a great follower of yours. Each day I used to rise with what you were speaking from Tokyo and went to bed with what you were preaching from New York. I bought when you told me to and sold when you scared me to. During the NASDAQ run I made a few multibaggers but then lost all of it. You would remember how you scolded me for not having applied stop losses. That was after the stocks went below those levels. But I continued to believe in you and your community. I made money in banking, sugar and construction, lost a few here and there. On the whole I did not do better then what I could have managed myself but still I enjoyed each moment of it. In June I lost quite a fortune on your Sterlite and Hindustan Zinc call. That was because the LME prices fell and I was taken off guard. As usual you rebuked me for not having put in stop losses.

During the current carnage when the index fell to 8800 one particular member from your community stormed the TV channels from Hong Kong and preached gloom, boom and doom. The local ones told me to stay away till the dust gets settled. Again I obliged and cut all my long positions converting them for cash. I booked profits in all the counters that I had got in early. This was because you advised me to take the profits home. For the losers you advised that there is no point selling at these levels and as it always happens I listened.

Investors wishing to save themselves from the bloom gloom and doom were advised me to go on a long holiday. I could not go on that holiday since it would have cost money. Another member from your community asked me to keep 30% in cash, a few told me to wait for the US interest rate cues while the others were preparing for a US led global recession and urgedgulliable investors like me to buy gold and silver. Theysaid that these would be the saviors.

At an index level of 8800 the largest fund house from the land of the rising sun talked about an index level of 7000above which they would not invest. Does any one know what they did after making that statement?

When ever I asked you something you were uncomfortable in responding you called it momentum and I thought that these stocks were for the greedy. But after having suffered because of my shortcomings (in not being able to understand you correctly) I have a few questions:

1) Doctors, engineers, accountants do pass some examinations before being called experts. They undergo rigorous training and then only they are allowed to advise. DO you along with members of your community undergo the same test before advising millions of fools like me on TV.

2) Do you ever look back and see how many of your recommendations went right and how many went wrong. If so how so if not why not?

3) Do you ever feel guilty either morally or ethically when investors lose money on your recommendations.

  1. You have a habit of using vague words like:

n Buy on declines

n Should give you 20% return. Whether the stock is at Rs 700 or Rs 850 you talk of the same 20% returns.

n Cautious optimism.

n Apply strict stop losses â Please name me one person who has made money by applying strict stop losses except the person who sells subscription for such advice.

n Momentum investing â If buying on a break out and selling on stop losses is not momentum investing then what is? Yet you prefer to talk of stocks that you do not understand as momentum investing.

5) Most of the time your analysis is historic. You say this stock has made a 52 week high at so and so and then retraced itself to so and so and now is trading at so and so. You know the introduction that takes 70% of you analysis does not help me. I can see it in the pink papers and that costs Rs 2.00 only.

**6) I am tired of hearing words like supports, resistances, 200 day moving averages, Fibonacci, retrenchments RSIâs etc **

7) Each day you looked at the NASDAQ and the Nikkei and told us where we would go. Over the last 5 years the NASDAQ has gone no where but we have gone up by more then 4 times.** Do you remember the critical days when you went wrong?**

8) When stocks fell you blamed sentiment when they went up you said liquidity. Why canât you tell us before hand as to what will happen? Otherwise there is no difference between you and me.

Yours Truly

âThe small investorâ

A bruised battered and mauled Bull

Edited by basant - 23/Aug/2006 at 6:57pm
Source :http://www.theequitydesk.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=213

All I can say is that I hope this doesn’t happen with valuepickr…
The forum admins have been great so far, but every now and then a few of the calls are bound to go wrong. If people put crazy faith in valuepickr and lose their shirt, will they blame valuepickr instead of themselves?
Many other stock market forums have collapsed valuepickr will have to really change the game to make sure it doesn’t go that way. But that requires a lot of effort and personal commitment. Forum admins are incredibly passionate and have done a great job so far, but now that they have become ultra high net individuals and have gained fame will they continue to have an interest in maintaining a forum? (Will a warren Buffett or rakesh jhunjhunwala ever like to be an admin of a forum)

Crowd sourced stock picking in valuepickr has been a great idea and has worked great so far (kudos to the admins) but it remains to be seen if it is ultimately sustainable.

Dear VPites,

I have been a silent member of this excellent forum for more than 2 years. The passion, dedication and generosity in sharing of information of the members here is excellent. I have benefited a lot in terms of experience, learning and monetary gains from the members contributions . As long as members continue to stick to the principles laid down by Forum admins and top contributors, this forum will remain a great place to learn and benefit from Investing.

A must read article for all who blindly follow so called experts and loose
their hard earned money.these people never gave advise to sell stocks,they
always give buy or hold recommendations.they are paid for their opinions
and comments.Thanks for posting this article.Eye opening for those who
follow them without making any effort and want to become rich in one day.